13 min read
Where have all the babies gone? AI and population decline
Birth rates are at record lows just as AI arrives to unsettle young people's sense of a secure future. Neil Johnson and I talk about why marriage and children have become a capstone rather than a cornerstone, and what that means for the church.
I joined Neil Johnson on 20twenty on Vision Christian Radio on 5 March 2025. This is a lightly edited transcript of our conversation. You can listen to the full interview above.
Neil: Let's talk about changing demographics and the escalating influence of artificial intelligence, in light of an ageing population and falling fertility rates. Our guest is asking: where have all the babies gone? With such monumental change, we can't help but ask what impact the arrival of AI will have. Alister Cameron serves with Power to Change, formerly Campus Crusade for Christ. Alister, welcome back to 20twenty.
Alister: Thank you, Neil. Great to be here.
From cornerstone to capstone
Neil: Let me start with the question: where have all the babies gone? Before we get into AI, this is a major thing, and it's all around us. We all know there are fewer babies today.
Alister: Yes, Neil, and if we don't get too far into AI in this conversation because fertility is such a big topic, we'll leave it at that. As a caveat, I'm mindful that there are people who desperately want children and can't have them, and I don't want to be insensitive to that. In a population context, "fertility" means who's having babies and how many, not the ability to have them.
Every generation asks: at what point in life should we settle down and get married, and when should we have children? And generations are changing how they answer. One helpful way to see it is that in past generations, perhaps yours and mine, Neil, marriage and children were what you might call a cornerstone: something you build the rest of your life around, an early building block of the good life.
According to the sociologist Andrew Cherlin, younger generations increasingly see marriage and children as a capstone achievement. It doesn't come at the start. It comes at the end. First you need a number of other building blocks in place: a mortgage, a lifestyle, a car, some travel out of your system, and, crucially, confidence. You need to feel you've landed somewhere you can then do these other things. That's a dramatic shift. It's never happened before. And the fruit of it, at a macro level, is that population is peaking. We're simply not having the numbers of children we used to, almost right across the world.
Neil: From time immemorial, marriage and children were how you reduced risk. You needed children to look after you in old age and run the farm. In an agrarian society, and even today for people on the land, children were the assurance that the family property would continue. Like an insurance policy.
Alister: Absolutely. Risk and insurance are a good way of looking at it. Historically, if you were well into your twenties and not having children, there was a big question mark over you. Now, trend data on Gen Z, roughly 15 to 30-year-olds, though demographers' definitions vary, suggests that 50 per cent of Gen Z women won't have a child before 30. For various reasons, children are being postponed, typically until around 30. And perhaps up to half of those who reach 30 without children will never have one, for voluntary or involuntary reasons. So Gen Z women are twice as likely as the previous generation to say they'll never have children, or to have them very late. And as you'd expect, Neil, if a couple isn't seriously thinking about children until 30, they're much less likely to have a large family. So we're seeing birth rates fall to all-time lows, well below replacement.
Can immigration fix it?
Neil: And that has all sorts of ramifications. Replacement rate is about 2.1 children per woman, and people ask how you have 0.1 of a child! To keep the economy growing, which is how governments tend to think, they have to address that differently, and immigration is the solution we're seeing.
Alister: That's true, but it's not the only solution. I'm not an expert, but this fascinates me, because it's one of maybe seven global megatrends the demographers and scientists are studying. Efforts so far to reverse falling fertility have largely not worked. Immigration is definitely one response. But as you and I know, the problem with immigration is that you're bringing people from somewhere else, and they come with culture, language and various kinds of baggage. I'm a strong believer in migration in principle, but the devil's in the detail, and you can create all kinds of cultural disruption, as the UK and much of Europe are experiencing right now. So Australia must keep a focus on immigration, but it can't be the only way we address this.
For context, Neil, Australia's high point was 1961, in the middle of the baby boom, when the average Australian woman had 3.55 children. Today we're down to 1.63 births per woman, less than half. Granted, the baby boom was a peak. But with replacement at 2.1, the existing population of Australia, everyone living here, is now progressively dwindling. Globally, population is expected to peak at somewhere over 9 billion, perhaps 9.1 or 9.2 billion, around 2060, and then the whole world starts heading down. You have to look to Africa and a few other places to find countries where fertility is healthily above replacement. Even India is no longer one of them. So ultimately immigration won't solve the problem either. Either the world works out how to encourage family, and the values and economics that support it, along with a range of other factors, or the world's population is, in the longer term, in decline.
Neil: And demographers are saying nations like China and India could see significant declines as early as the end of this decade. So it's not way off in the future. It's happening now. What factors do you think are driving declining fertility, globally and here in Australia?
Why fewer babies?
Alister: There are many, they're varied, and they're contentious, Neil, so I'll throw a few out and you grab any that catch your attention.
First, reproductive technologies. Once upon a time, part of being husband and wife was the reality that nature happens. Now we can largely avoid that. The pill and abortion very obviously give people much greater control over reproduction, and so fewer babies are born, because it used to be not entirely a matter of choice. It was also just what happened.
Then, and I don't want to push this one too far, but it's worth considering: the social acceptance today of homosexuality and transgender identities, in a cohort with much lower fertility rates in general. They're simply not having children like the general population.
Neil: So even our attitudes to sexuality are affecting fertility rates. It's not just one small group off to the side. It affects how everyone thinks about having children.
Alister: It does. There are also strong economic factors, like women's participation in the workforce, which we all applaud. But there's a straightforward correlation: the more educated a woman is, the later and the fewer children she tends to have. What has been a blessing to our society, bringing women from being uneducated into a place of empowerment and choice, all of which properly understood is a great thing, has logically led to fewer children.
And there's the clear economic consequence of a shifting demographic. In Australia more baby boomers are retiring, moving out of economic productivity into a kind of dependency, hopefully on their own resources but not always, while fewer people are coming into the job market to supply a strong labour force. That makes it harder for a young person to save for a house and so on, because we're in a weaker economic position.
The case for marriage
Neil: Let's talk about one particular factor: the desirability of traditional marriage, as Christians understand it. A man and a woman who love one another and their children, and go on to build a life together, a lifelong commitment to raising those children. We could point fingers at all sorts of things, but this is one of the factors affecting the birth rate, isn't it?
Alister: It is, and it's really interesting. Some listeners may have come across Louise Perry. I'm scanning my bookshelf for her book as we speak. She's written a secular book that lands on a very sensible, Christian-sounding conviction: that the sexual revolution has been particularly destructive for women. There are conditions under which a woman is almost instinctively most comfortable settling down and having children, and they're similar for men, and the traditional picture of marriage is really that, with a cherry on top. But the looser, weaker ties of de facto relationships and various forms of cohabitation don't give couples the confidence they need to settle down.
So I think one of the wonderful things about the Christian worldview and the gospel message for our generation is that in Christ we uphold a vision of what male and female are, what the marriage relationship is, and what bringing children into the world is all about. That vision is becoming more and more revolutionary. We need to celebrate it, and we need to be experts at it.
AI and a generation's insecurity
Neil: Celebrating and getting better at what traditional marriage contributes to a society. Now, this may be where AI intersects. Lots of jobs are at risk and there's a lot of change. Maybe jobs lost will be taken up in other ways, but there's increased job insecurity, and people thinking, "The security of my future doesn't look good, so I might not have children." Any thoughts on that insecurity in the minds of younger Australians?
Alister: Absolutely, and it's at epidemic levels. In the last year or two, one study asked senior executives and new entrants to the workforce how confident they were that their job would still exist in a decade. Only 12 per cent of senior executives were concerned, but around 63 per cent of Gen Z entrants, people in their twenties trying to make their way, were. That was very much about the impact of AI: automation, robotics, computerisation. Some of it may be more folklore and speculation than reality, but there's a sense out there that AI is a transformative technology. For a younger generation already facing everything we've talked about, adding the question of whether the kind of job they're aiming for will even exist is quite challenging.
Anecdotally, Neil, I've spent the last few days on some software development I needed to do. I have a background in software development. But this time I plugged an AI agent into my computer, told it where the software I wanted to work on was, and essentially instructed it, and it went off and built it under my supervision. It won't be long before even my supervision isn't that valuable. I look at people in my family who, like me, have gone down a path of software-related work, and realise it's one of the very first in line for complete disruption, if not destruction. I can fully understand how scary it would be right now for a young man or woman with a computer science degree, say, to try to read the tea leaves and work out where it's all going and what it means for their economic security.
Neil: Maybe it's a case of adapting as early as you can to this new age of AI, so you can have some confidence about your future, your future marriage and your future children. It's rare for people to choose childlessness outright. Maybe they choose fewer children. But this new day is even causing a mental health crisis around the thought of having children.
Alister: That's right, depending on where in the world you look and how you analyse it. I don't want to be too quick to speak for Gen Z, but the observation is that mental health has become a big talking point for that younger generation. To their credit, they talk about it. They don't have previous generations' hesitations about the language of mental health. And from a Christian perspective, I think we need to understand that there's a particular flavour of anxiety in the water, and it's a tremendous opportunity for the gospel. We have a different definition of success, a different definition of the good life, and a very particular view of what it means to do life and relationships well.
A distinct people
Neil: So as things change, I hear you saying the church is going to look very different from the world, as long as people in church take the bull by the horns, adapt to the new environment around AI, and understand a redefinition of success and what it means for marriage and family. And my suspicion, perhaps to end on, is that a lot of people outside the church may become a little jealous of what's happening inside it: in the families and relationships of this whole ecosystem of knowing God and the powerful message of the gospel. What are your thoughts on what the church ought to look like?
Alister: On some levels, Neil, AI is no different from anything else that's come along and risked challenging, threatening or derailing us, or causing us anxiety, like everyone else. The difference is that we take these things as they come, technological innovation and social change, and run them through a really confident filter of biblical truth that we live out in a community called the church, with our own distinct traditions, customs, values, rules, rituals and language. These things strengthen us. They come out of our inquiry into scripture, but they don't stay as conversations about personal morality. They're translated into how we live. In that sense we urge and encourage each other to experience the supernatural hope that comes from knowing Jesus, to live in the power of the Holy Spirit, and to work hard, I don't know if "fight" is the right word, on Christian community, this distinct community in the world.
The Apostle Peter talks about us as foreigners and exiles, sojourners in a strange land. There's a distinctiveness about us. We need to be proud of it, lean into it, explore it and experiment. And we need to get really good at saying no to things, or at least being cautious, thoughtful and measured about what we see happening in the world, deciding whether and how we let those things into our lives, and passing them through the grid of biblical truth and what it means to live as Christians. Because, as Paul says, everything is permissible, but not everything is beneficial.
Neil: Really good words of wisdom. Boiling it down: get good at being a Christian, because our nation needs you to be good at being a Christian right now. There's a lot to learn in that, which comes down to being a disciple of Christ, aligning your life with him, right down to where the rubber hits the road day to day, including marriage, family and a long-term future. You can connect with Alister at powertochange.org.au. Power to Change is much bigger now than when people started calling it the biggest mission organisation in the world, because of its amazing work on university and school campuses around the world. Alister, thanks so much for your insights today on 20twenty.
Alister: My pleasure, Neil. Thanks so much, mate.


