3 min read
Words as weapons: when a commenter upstages a journalist!
A Guardian writer chose insensitive timing to lecture Australia while the bushfires still burned, and one commenter upstaged her completely.
I love this "age of social media". We're seeing the "populace" given voice in ways that have never existed before. Here's an example from today...

In a Guardian article just published, entitled "The 'continent of smoke' is still burning", writer (and Guardian Weekly editor) Natalie Bennett chooses very insensitive timing to discuss Australian urban planning, population, climate and such favourite lefty topics. She doesn't seem bothered that the search for Victorian bushfire fatalities is not yet concluded, and the large number of irate commenters have expressed their disgust in no uncertain terms.
It seems clear that Natalie is not about to win any awards for journalistic excellence for this piece, but I invite you to consider this comment from one Edmund McMahon, which goes to prove that a commenter can well and truly upstage a writer, if his prose is good enough. I submit that Mr McMahon has done just that with an very well crafted, erudite and scathing response. When writing is as good as this, there is no need for expletives or rudeness to "put someone firmly in their place"... just the impressive force of linguistic excellence.
Judge for yourself:
Hi Natalie,
I have read the Guardian and the Guardian Weekly since I was about ten. This is the article which has finally persuaded me it is time to stop. Do you not think it is slightly regrettable to choose the death by burning of perhaps 200 people as an occasion to sermonise against the stupidity of the victims, and to admonish a bereaved society for existing in the first place?
Your article is - as others have pointed out - crass, moralistic, poorly written and grotesquely smug. A core of unexceptionable (if rather dimly grasped) facts, are wrapped up in a rhetoric which caters to a punitive fantasy dear to some Britons who are anxious to displace colonial guilt.
The real Australia (virgin nature and soulful indigenes) must be rescued from the yoke of modernity by the progressive consciences of Clapham! A population of 20 million must be reduced by four-fifths and a modern economy must revert to the harvesting of free-range kangaroos! I do hope you are getting up a petition against these draconian colonial 'planning laws' which prevent us colonials from living in a 'caravan' or 'small bark humpy', as nature so clearly intended.
Professor Flannery's arguments about population and agricultural sustainability (which BTW have been revised several times since you and he last chatted 20 years ago) have a lot of merit. But, as he would no doubt point out, traditional land management practices can only inform contemporary solutions. To propose that Australia can solve today's problems by reverting to firestick farming is about as useful as suggesting that Britain could rescue its financial system by embracing barter.
Still, thanks for your input. It seems a shame that such insight, expertise and sensitivity is wasted on this expatriate preaching to the converted. Please come home, run for public office, save us from ourselves.
What a delight to read. His polemic takes on a life of its own. This is words as weapons.
So be warned. If you think you have the upper hand as a mainstream media (MSM) journo, you don't. The social media revolution is upon us and this is the day of the commenter putting the writer in his/her place... and I, for one, love it.
Have you seen other examples of this? How have you seen the "locus of control" in the online conversation shifting from the few to the many, from the MSM to the Average Joe?


