Asking questions to defend the faith

You don't need every scientific and philosophical answer to defend your faith. Often the best response to a hard objection is a good question, which is exactly how Jesus did it. Neil Johnson and I work through eight common objections.

Listen to the interview20twenty · Vision Christian Radio

I joined Neil Johnson on 20twenty on Vision Christian Radio on 25 March 2026. This is a lightly edited transcript of our conversation. You can listen to the full interview above.

Neil: We're turning to questions as a key tactic for defending your faith. As Christians we may be inclined to think we need scientific and philosophical answers for people, and there's no doubt a place for equipping ourselves. But maybe the most effective way of defending your faith is knowing the right questions to ask. Alister Cameron works with Power to Change, formerly Campus Crusade for Christ, and he's the Australian ambassador for the Finishing the Task initiative. Alister, welcome back to 20twenty.

Alister: Thank you for having me, Neil. Great to be here.

Intimidated by the hard questions

Neil: Sometimes I think we don't share our faith, our testimony, the things God is doing, because we don't feel equipped to answer all the scientific and philosophical questions. Is that something you've come across?

Alister: It is, and I've been quite intimidated by it. In my early years of coming to faith, I was quite a heady young man. I got caught up in the intellectual side of things and less so the heart, which is often normal for a young man. I found it intimidating, because I felt my job was to convince everybody of the truth, as if they'd come to Jesus by some intellectual path.

Even more recently, three or four years ago, I was between large projects, and one thing led to another and I had the opportunity to stand for the upper house at the last Victorian state election with Family First. Your listeners will know Lyle Shelton and the great work that team is doing. As part of that, I was given some media training, because if you end up in politics, there's a good chance you'll have to stand in front of a journalist.

If any listeners are wondering what it's like to face someone aggressively atheistic who wants to ask dreadful questions about the Christian faith, imagine being a political candidate in front of a trained journalist. In that training, one of my colleagues was completely undone, and it was only a test scenario. Politicians have learned the art of dialogue with people both easy and difficult: making a point, controlling a conversation, keeping it on track in the direction they want. So I want to share a very thin slice of what's a very broad topic: asking questions as a tactic.

Vision is based in Queensland, so can I tell you this one, Neil? Queenslanders will love it. Years ago, a journalist asked Premier Joh Bjelke-Petersen, in exasperation I assume, "Why do you always answer questions with another question?" And Premier Joh famously replied, "What's wrong with that?"

Neil: That's right. My journalism career goes back far enough that I was often in the crowd when Joh was "feeding the chooks" at a press conference.

How Jesus used questions

Neil: We'll rattle through a bunch of objections shortly. But first: how did Jesus respond under pressure? Was this a tactic he used too?

Alister: He really did. If listeners go back to the Gospels after this, notice how often Jesus answers a question, teases something out of someone, gets the penny to drop, or puts a pebble in their shoe to bother them, by asking a question. Often, having been asked a question, he doesn't answer it. He flips it into another question.

Surveying the Gospels: when Jesus is talking to his critics, he's often exposing logical fallacies or hypocrisy in their attacks, and the goal is to silence them, to send them away to have a long think and stop bothering him. When he's talking to the curious, people on a journey of discovery, he wants to push them along it, which is often what we're doing too. Then he's trying to spark deeper reflection: he's asked a surface question and takes it deeper. With his disciples, he's testing and growing their faith, as in "Who do you say I am?" And with the suffering, it's interesting: "Do you want to be healed?" It should be obvious the person wanted to be healed, but Jesus wants an expression of desire and of faith from them.

Eight objections, and a question for each

Neil: I've got a list of objections here. To get through them quickly, I'll give you each one, and you give us a short explanation and the kind of question you might ask in reply.

"If God is good and all-powerful, why is there so much suffering?"

Alister: I won't put on any special voices! Can I invite listeners to consider: if you were asked that right now, what's your strategy for answering it? It's a really challenging question, it's asked often, and it often trips us up.

So here's a strategy. First, validate the pain of that person's experience. Chances are they're not asking it frivolously. Something real is going on in their life. Then pivot, and you need to rehearse this and think it through, to the origins of morality and the value of free will. The question might be: "If there's no God, by what standard do you decide the world is broken or evil, rather than just normal?" You're acknowledging that their question comes from a heart experiencing something, but pointing out that if you take God out of the equation, you need to justify having a valid moral framework to define good and evil in the first place. That's a bit philosophical, Neil, but it's a very important conversation that can open up from there.

"Why should I believe only Jesus is the truth?"

Neil: We could probably do a whole program on each of these. Next: why should I believe only Jesus is ultimate truth?

Alister: That's a common one too. Have a think about how you'd answer it. I think a key strategy is to point out that every worldview, philosophy and belief makes an exclusive claim, with the possible exception of nihilism, which rejects all belief. Islam makes an exclusive claim. Naturalism and atheism make exclusive claims. So the question might be: "Every religion and philosophy claims to have a handle on the truth. Why does the idea of one way, which is what we claim in Jesus, feel offensive to you, when 'many ways', which also excludes certain views, feels right?" It helps someone realise that any set of ideas they pick up makes exclusive claims. You have to choose one, and I've chosen Jesus.

Neil: And that's very exclusive. "I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me." Saying that these days gets you into all sorts of trouble.

"Why would a loving God send anyone to hell?"

Alister: I love the answer Wes Huff gave to this recently on The Diary of a CEO, one of the biggest podcasts in the world, up there with Joe Rogan, with more viewers than any TV show. Wes Huff, a Christian apologist from Canada, was asked exactly this, and his strategy was to reframe hell as God's respect for human autonomy. If we won't say to God, "Your will be done," then ultimately he will say to those who don't follow him, "Your will be done." So the question might be: "Would it actually be loving for God to force someone into his presence for eternity, if they spent their whole life trying to avoid him?" I think that's really powerful, and it worked wonderfully on that podcast.

"Doesn't evolution and modern science kill Christianity?"

Alister: Last time I was on your show, Neil, we talked about how the new atheism and evolutionary theory are on the back foot, because so much wonderful science is revealing just how intelligently creation is designed. But as a strategy, I'd say science has always done its best, and always will, to explain the how of things, while faith explains the why. So the question might be: "Do you think the laws of physics are the reason the universe exists, or just a description of how it behaves? Can a map ever explain why the land exists in the first place?" Science is the map. That gets someone thinking about the proper place of science, which never touches the faith questions, the meaning questions. Often that will get you a tremendous distance.

"Faith is just a crutch for weak people"

Alister: It's not wrong to acknowledge human weakness. We all have weaknesses. But the strategy is to challenge the idea that strength is the same as truth. As questions: "If Christianity is true, wouldn't it be weaker to pretend we don't need help? And if it's a crutch, why does it so often lead people into harder lives of sacrifice and persecution?" Here you can illustrate from your own experience, from scripture and from history: Christians have been among the people who paid the greatest price for their faith and showed extraordinary strength in living it out. That puts paid to the idea that Jesus gathers weak people around him. Maybe they're weak at the start, but he makes them strong, and the testimony of history proves it.

"You can't prove God, so I can't believe"

Alister: A lot of people will guess this one. Nobody's daily life works on purely empirical knowledge, with everything proven fact and no belief involved. It's about distinguishing scientific proof from evidence. The question might be: "What kind of evidence would actually convince you? If God appeared to you right now, would you believe in him, or assume you were having a neurological hallucination?" That helps them see they may be at risk of not believing even if God did show up, and also that they exercise faith every minute of the day: getting on a plane, a train or into a car. There's faith in every decision we make, because none of us has perfect knowledge.

"The church is full of hypocrites, bigots and predators"

Alister: First, humility, and an acknowledgement that this could come from a cheap place, as a throwaway line, or from real pain. Sometimes there's a story, and we need to ask questions that draw it out, like "Is that coming from your own experience?"

But if it's more of a debating tactic, it helps to distinguish between the patient and the physician, and to use their moral outrage to point back to Jesus' own standards. The question might be: "Are you judging Christianity by the people who fail to follow Jesus, or by Jesus himself?" That can sound like a get-out-of-jail-free card for us, but in the right context you can add: "Doesn't your outrage at their behaviour confirm there's a standard of good they're failing to meet?" Asked well, those questions elevate Jesus and put humans back in their place. You're not making excuses, but you're still making a strong point.

"The Bible is full of contradictions, cruelty and even genocide"

Alister: One response is to invite people to read the Bible with you, wherever possible. If you're in the right kind of relationship with the right person, sitting down with them and working through scripture with a discovery process is wonderful. "Would you like to read the Bible with me and dig into these things?" is a really valid response.

Beyond that, encourage them to look at scripture without imposing their own worldview on it. It doesn't solve every question or settle things finally, but you might ask: "When you read those difficult passages, are you looking at them through a 21st-century Western lens, or letting them speak in the context of their original ancient world and what people understood back then?"

Neil: Sometimes I respond to that one by saying: if that's the case, it might suggest that God, when he's wearing his judge's hat, isn't as nice as you think he is.

"I'm fine. I don't need religion"

Neil: What about the person who says, "I'm fine as I am, thank you. Keep your religion to yourself"?

Alister: Sometimes that's the end of the conversation. Sometimes you're knocking on a door that won't open, and it's "Great chat, good talking with you," and you move on. You can discern that. But if there's an opening, try moving the conversation from being a good person to something deeper, the purpose of existence. You might ask: "If the goal of life is just to be fine, what happens when things aren't fine, like death or suffering? Does 'fine' give you a meaning that outlasts your lifespan, or your good days?" You might hear this from a young person, but the older someone gets, the more cause they've had to reflect and admit, "My life isn't always fine."

"I don't need church and all its rules"

Neil: One more. If you're a Christian, you're likely to be attached to a local church, and someone says, "I don't need church and all the rules." What's the best question in response?

Alister: There's always a balance in the world between form and function, and function is total chaos if it doesn't sit within some form. People often don't realise they live their own lives by a set of rules. They want to put that on Christianity, but it's not consistent with how they live. Strategically, we can clarify that Christianity is a relationship based on grace, not a checklist of rules. So the question might be: "Is it the rules you dislike, or the idea of an authority other than yourself? And if God is the creator of life, wouldn't he be the best one to write the owner's manual for running it?" That honours God in his place and helps people settle down a bit and think, "Maybe I do need this."

Neil: You needed to be listening carefully to follow every one of those objections. We could talk for another half hour on each. Alister, always great getting your insights. You can connect with Alister at powertochange.org.au, where you'll find the very useful My Friends resource, and at finishingthetask.com. Alister, thank you so much for sharing your insights with us today on 20twenty.

Alister: Hope it's been helpful. Thank you, Neil.

Get new posts by email

Essays and notes, sent when they're published. No spam, unsubscribe in one click.