Chaos follows when we detach from biblical foundations

With Giggle v Tickle back in court, Neil Johnson and I talk about how language has been turned into a weapon, how Australia got here, and why Christians need clarity, courage and conviction.

Listen to the interview20twenty · Vision Christian Radio

I joined Neil Johnson on 20twenty on Vision Christian Radio on 6 August 2025. This is a lightly edited transcript of our conversation. You can listen to the full interview above.

Neil: Chaos and confusion when you detach from biblical foundations. You might have caught the case back in court this week: Giggle v Tickle. It centres on Roxanne Tickle, a transgender woman who sued Giggle for Girls, a social media app founded by Sall Grover. Last year the Federal Court found that Sall Grover and Giggle had unlawfully discriminated against the 54-year-old, and Sall Grover is now appealing. Alister Cameron from Power to Change has been thinking biblically about the principles Christians need as Australia increasingly adopts what he calls chaos and confusion. Alister, welcome back to 20twenty.

Alister: Thank you for having me, Neil. Good to be back.

How we got here

Neil: Just the name of the case, Giggle v Tickle, captures your imagination. The nation's eyes are on the court this week, and chaos and confusion may be why it got there in the first place. What are your impressions?

Alister: You hear "Giggle v Tickle" and you'd be forgiven for thinking it had something to do with people driving big red cars and singing cute songs to children, but it's nothing of the sort. As you said, Roxanne Tickle, the applicant, a year ago won a case against Giggle for Girls and Sall Grover on the basis of gender identity discrimination, something we had no idea about until relatively recently. Now Sall Grover and Giggle are back in court to appeal, and the question is how it'll go. Sadly, I'm not convinced it'll go well. There are various ways things could be decided in her favour, such as the special measures that allow for female-only spaces, but it's really sticky.

It actually goes back to a 2013 amendment to the Sex Discrimination Act. I don't want to get caught up in the legalities, Neil, but it's worth highlighting. In 2013, at the very end of the Gillard government before Kevin Rudd came back, the government amended the Sex Discrimination Act 1984, ostensibly to create a level playing field. They removed the biological definitions of man and woman and enshrined a concept of changeable sex, around the idea of gender identity. I honestly wonder what the politicians at the time thought that would mean. But what it has done is unleash chaos and confusion.

And it's very much about language. If we tried to dissect this philosophically, in terms of the movement of ideas, we'd be here for hours, talking about the last 500 years of philosophy, about Nietzsche and others along the way. But where we've landed is a place where activists and influencers are using language and flipping it on its head, so that words that meant one thing now mean another. A woman is one thing, but suddenly there's a "trans woman", which is something very different.

Neil: I think Julia Gillard thought she'd found a masterstroke for dealing with the difference between male and female: abolish male and female in the Sex Discrimination Act and suddenly everybody's equal. She couldn't have imagined the chaos and confusion that would follow. There is a simple solution being put forward, which is to put those words back into the Act. But politicians seem very reluctant even to have the debate.

Alister: Props to Senator Alex Antic from South Australia, and others, who are trying to reverse those changes. Given the cultural tide, I think they have Buckley's and none of succeeding. But in the history of legislative change in this country, you do have to stand up and put these proposals forward. Maybe they get knocked back in the Senate or the lower house, or both, but there's a process, and props to those doing it. There's a strong cultural tide at the moment, and we'll see where it goes.

Women are the losers

Neil: I'll anticipate that truth will ultimately win these debates, in all the discomfort of court cases and the like. Even J.K. Rowling, the Harry Potter author, who doesn't call herself a Christian, has thrown her support behind Sall Grover with the comment "May the best woman win." She celebrated the UK Supreme Court ruling that, under Britain's Equality Act, the legal definition of woman refers to a biological female, not gender identity. So the UK is a bit ahead of Australia here, and you don't have to be a Christian to recognise the difference between male and female. That's an indicator that people who don't even claim to be Christian recognise a level of truth here.

Alister: Yes, and there's a critical difference. UK sex discrimination law doesn't have the biological component removed. What Australia did in 2013, they didn't do, which allowed the court to decide in favour of biological sex. And props to J.K. Rowling for funding a significant part of that process. But in Australia we changed our legislation specifically to advance queer and trans interests, if you like, and in removing biology we led ourselves into this chaos and confusion.

It's ironic, because the Sex Discrimination Act 1984 was written in large part to put men and women on an equal footing. But what's demonstrably the case in Giggle v Tickle, whichever way it goes, is that women are the losers. Where we'd worked so hard for women to be on a level legal playing field with men, we now have the opposite: men moving into women-only spaces and declaring that such spaces aren't allowed to exist, and talking nonsense about gender identity as distinct from biological sex.

So first, truth has gone out the window, leading to chaos and confusion. And second, there's the abuse of women and girls. That's where it really hurts, and as a society we have to work our way through it. There's something so fundamentally true about this that I'm hopeful that in the long run this woke nonsense will find its way out and truth will emerge. But what damage and pain is being caused in the process?

Language as a baseball bat

Neil: Ultimately it has to come back to our legislators to change the law, but there'll be plenty of court processes first. And we might wonder about the judges on the bench. As reported, one of the judges revealed her adherence to radical gender ideology by using the term "cis woman". There's something in the language used that seems to reveal people's hearts, even of those on the bench. Any thoughts, cautiously, on what this says about our legal system?

Alister: Cautiously, of course. You're making a very good point about language. When someone puts pronouns in their email signature, or puts the word "cis" in front of something, which we'd never heard of a few years ago, there's a deliberate use of language to relativise truth, to introduce what is actually meaninglessness into our discourse. It does three things. It obscures moral clarity: it's trying to teach us a new morality, which is no morality at all. It inverts truth: it's actually lies. A trans woman is not a woman. A trans woman is a man. And it disrupts rational thinking. Taken together, language has become a baseball bat to beat us into submission.

So the capacity of Christians to speak truth plainly, straightforwardly and courageously is a really important piece of the puzzle. Many years ago, as I was meditating on this, I felt the Lord gave me three words, which a friend repeated to me only yesterday, so obviously I'm not original in anything: clarity, courage and conviction. These are in the nature of Christ himself, and they're what's needed in this hour.

Many of us as Christians are tempted to buy into the language nonsense, this messing with truth. We sometimes think that to be loving, to be Christ-like, we need to be conciliatory. But what ends up happening is that the simple, plain speaking of truth is obscured.

Put your own mask on first

Neil: So how might Christians confront this chaos and confusion? As you say, we're reluctant even about pronouns. We'll use the wrong ones so we don't get into deep water. Maybe there's a need for a bit of civil disobedience around pronouns. But what does the Bible say? Is there wisdom from God to help us make sense of truth and speaking in love?

Alister: First, there's that rather non-biblical image of putting your own mask on in a plane before helping the children and others. The first thing for us as Christians is to fill ourselves up with God's truth, to look after our own minds and thinking. Ephesians 4 is a beautiful chapter in a book I've read through about half a dozen times in the last 24 hours in preparation for this, Neil. Paul writes: "Then we will no longer be infants, tossed back and forth by the waves, and blown here and there by every wind of teaching and by the cunning and craftiness of people in their deceitful scheming." Doesn't that sound like what we're dealing with now? "Instead, speaking the truth in love, we will grow to become in every respect the mature body of him who is the head, that is, Christ."

So the church is where the fullness of Christ is found. It's where truth is. The first thing is that we as the church need to put the figurative mask on ourselves and be absolutely anchored in that truth. There are disciplines around that: getting into the word of God, and filling ourselves up in every way with the wisdom that comes from the Spirit.

Then there's the prophetic side of speaking truth to our neighbours. Ephesians 4:25: "Therefore each of you must put off falsehood and speak truthfully to your neighbour, for we are all members of one body." I want to caveat this: I'm not asking people to roll up their sleeves and go blazing into public spaces declaring truth and getting themselves into trouble. There's a wisdom of the Spirit that comes with this. But there's a bedrock principle that truth speaks into chaos and confusion and brings order.

Think of the very first chapter of Genesis, with the Spirit of God hovering over the chaotic waters. God comes into that and, in an act of creation, brings order out of chaos. That's fundamental to the message of Christ through his church. We carry a message of order to chaos: clarity, courage and conviction in the face of the craziness of the world.

The right words, spoken boldly

Neil: And we're warned what happens when we detach from that foundation. In Romans 1, Paul says they "exchanged the truth about God for a lie, and worshipped and served created things rather than the Creator", and that exchange leads people to abandon the natural order and morality. That's what we're seeing. Scripture not only tells us what happens when we detach, but now the detachment has happened, our challenge is how to regain ground.

Alister: That's right. There's a logic, a devilish one, to what's happening in the world as biblical truth is abandoned. Many people have said it far more eloquently than I will: many modern movements have very ancient roots. Even in Ephesians, Paul keeps returning to the devil, to what's going on in the heavenly places. He says, "Put on the full armour of God." Then he concludes that passage in Ephesians 6, and I'll read it because it's a good place to land. He asks people to pray for him:

"And pray in the Spirit on all occasions with all kinds of prayers and requests. With this in mind, be alert" (just such a good headline: be alert) "and always keep on praying for all the Lord's people. Pray also for me, that whenever I speak, words may be given me so that I will fearlessly make known the mystery of the gospel, for which I am an ambassador in chains. Pray that I may declare it fearlessly, as I should."

I pray that for myself, for you, Neil, and for our listeners: that the Lord would give us the right words when we speak. So Paul asks two things: that he'd be given the right words, and that he'd speak boldly. The world is going to go where the world is going. In the face of that chaos and confusion stands the clarity, courage and conviction of a church, a body of individual Christians soaked in the fullness of Christ, who can find the right words and speak them boldly. That's my prayer for us this morning, Neil.

Neil: Clarity, courage and conviction. Sall Grover is back in court with an appeal, and prominent Christians like Kirralie Smith, who leads Binary Australia, are also facing court cases. Kirralie has a quote that adds real weight here: "If it were really true that a person could change sex, why wouldn't they jump at the opportunity to prove it?" Of course it isn't proven and can't be. Ultimately truth will win, but there are processes to work through now. What impresses me is your ability to connect biblical foundations to modern events. The wisdom of God doesn't change. It's timeless, and it applies to this situation and to new ones yet to surface. Any initiatives coming up at Power to Change, or articles you're writing?

Alister: I'm about to have something published on the Daily Declaration website about the Australian Evangelism Roundtable, which we spoke about last time. I continue to be really excited about that, because our organisation, Power to Change, and a number of others are looking at what it would take to reach every Australian with the gospel by 2033. I don't have a specific initiative to share right now, but we're really trying to connect the dots across the body of Christ, so that united efforts of various shapes and flavours emerge over the next few years to get the word out more boldly and clearly, and so that individual Christians are trained to share the gospel more effectively, overcome the fears we naturally have, and become effective disciple makers. That's all in the pipeline.

Neil: Wonderful. You can connect with Alister at powertochange.org.au, and you can hear the passion in his voice. Alister, thanks so much for another great set of insights today on 20twenty.

Alister: My pleasure, Neil. Thanks so much.

Get new posts by email

Essays and notes, sent when they're published. No spam, unsubscribe in one click.