A Christ-like posture in a Christ-rejecting world

Fight, flight or freeze? Guest host Wendy Francis and I talk about how Christians and churches respond to rising hostility and nationalism, and why the biblical posture is a fourth option, faith.

Listen to the interview20twenty · Vision Christian Radio

I joined guest host Wendy Francis on 20twenty on Vision Christian Radio on 3 September 2025. This is a lightly edited transcript of our conversation. You can listen to the full interview above.

Wendy: It's great to welcome Alister Cameron back to 20twenty. Alister and his wife Gail are project leaders with the mission organisation Power to Change. Alister has been my colleague and will always be a loyal friend. He's dependable and kind, one of those people you could ring and he'd be there for you, so I'm grateful for him. He also has really good insight and a good understanding of current affairs, which makes him a very valued 20twenty contributor. Welcome back, Alister.

Alister: Thank you, Wendy. Always great to speak to you.

Our cultural moment

Wendy: There's a lot to say in a short time, so let's jump straight in. In Australia and other Western nations we seem to be seeing a rise in what I'll call nationalism, and it's affecting the Christian community too. The March for Australia rallies last weekend are an example of what I mean: good and bad, all in together. We're also seeing increasing hostility, moral decay and challenges to our faith in society. So what is the Christ-like posture Christians need, individually and as a church, in this cultural moment?

Alister: I've been thinking about that a lot. My first conviction is that, as Christians, we really need to meditate on who Jesus is: Jesus as the model for how we live, how we think and how we follow the Father. That takes a particular shape, a particular posture. And I wondered what mental model might help us think about it, particularly the different ways Christians respond when we gather as church.

For other reasons, I've been looking at, believe it or not, trauma-informed therapy.

Wendy: Oh no, we have enough trauma! I'm feeling traumatised already.

Alister: But I found it a helpful model, because it talks about fight, flight and freeze. Technically, that's a physiological reaction to a perceived threat, usually learned in childhood, or on the battlefield if you're a Vietnam vet, say. Fight is the instinct to confront. Flight is escaping. Freeze is becoming paralysed, or compromising. I've had reason to think about that in my own life and in the lives of my children and people I love, because people encounter trauma in life and have to work it out, maybe with some therapy.

I think it's not a bad mental model for how the church is responding to this cultural moment. We talk about the pendulum swinging between extremes in society. I feel like the pendulum has split, and it's at both extremes at once. You can find radical expressions of all sorts of positions in society today, in protest marches and in how people express themselves politically. And the church has to face that and ask: how do we stay not just sane, but prophetically on target with the Lord?

Wendy: Can I pick up on that pendulum? Remember those desk toys with the little balls? Lift one at one end and let it go, and they swing in beautiful harmony. But lift a ball at each end and swing them at the same time, and when they meet, it's a dead stop. If the church is divided and coming from different ends, we just stop. And God never wants us to just stop, does he? He wants us on the move.

Alister: That's right, and it's an important point. We use the word apostolic, meaning sent out. The Holy Spirit himself is sent from the Father to do his work in the body, and we in turn are called by God to go out into the world and be effective disciple makers. That's the Great Commission. But we're tempted to take different positions. So I found fight, flight and freeze helpful, and I believe there's a fourth word for what the church should do, which we'll come to.

Fight

Alister: When I think of fight, an aggressive, confrontational posture, I think of the movement called Christian nationalism. It's more in the US at the moment, though it's attempted to come here, and we've been talking about it since around the COVID period. There are certain high-profile men in the US taking a very muscular, very masculine approach that, if not verging on misogyny, goes right into it. And it can be quite attractive to young men who feel lost. But it's also very much about seizing the levers of political power.

Now, you and I, Wendy, have worked hard, you much longer than me, at the Australian Christian Lobby, so we know what it is to think long and deep about Christian political engagement. We've nuanced that, and the ACL has done very well. But the vision of Christians grabbing the levers of political power and taking over isn't something the Bible can ever make sense of, certainly not the New Testament. Yet there's a move in the church today towards that fighting instinct, reacting with a view to taking over politically, and you can imagine where that could go. It's not helpful. It's almost a psychology, a posture, that I don't think we ever see in the Lord.

Flight

Alister: Flight is the separatist option, the escape option. It's not being of the world to the point of not being in it at all. Think of the Amish and similar movements. I don't see so much of that, although there are people who've checked out of mission in favour of self-preservation. It may preserve purity, but it comes at the cost of abandoning our calling to be salt and light, engaged with the world. Jesus doesn't give us the option of stepping away from engagement with the powers and principalities. But we engage from a position of victory, confident that in Christ we have all we need. We're not allowed to check out or run away.

Wendy: It's tempting though, isn't it? There's a temptation at times to run away and hide.

Alister: There really is. And some churches and movements have institutionalised that as part of their character, and built a theology around it.

Freeze

Alister: Then there's freeze. From a church standpoint it's paralysis, capitulation, compromise. We try to make peace with a scary, evil world, but we end up compromising. We're so desperate for things to go well and so reluctant to ruffle feathers that we just stop and say, "All right, have it your way."

Dietrich Bonhoeffer, reflecting on his experience in World War II, wrote something I found helpful: "We have been silent witnesses of evil deeds; we have been drenched by many storms; we have learnt the arts of equivocation and pretence; experience has made us suspicious of others and kept us from being truthful and open; intolerable conflicts have worn us down and even made us cynical. Are we still of any use?"

Wendy: Wow.

Alister: I can understand that sentiment.

Faith

Alister: But I really want to get to what I think is the biblical posture, which is faith. Perhaps no surprise, faith is about standing firm. That's the emphasis of the spiritual warfare passage in Ephesians 6. In Matthew 24, Jesus talks about being alert and prepared. And faith recognises that grabbing the levers of political power isn't the answer. Our citizenship is somewhere else.

Faith calls us, like Jesus, to live a paradoxical life. We win by losing, as Jesus certainly did: the ultimate loss on the cross turned into the ultimate victory. We give in order to receive. We find freedom in surrender.

That's a whole other segment, I'm sure, but there's a very strong theme of freedom today, especially since COVID and in a lot of these marches. Nobody's denying it: freedom of speech, of assembly, of religion are all good things. But here's the paradox. As Christians, we come to Jesus and he sets us free from sin and death, and then we surrender our freedom to Jesus. Paul talks about how far he surrenders his freedom to make sure he doesn't put a stumbling block in front of weaker Christians, such as in the Corinthian church. There's so much in that.

So I'd encourage brothers and sisters to think long and hard about this: as we press deeper into faith, trusting that Jesus' way is the right way, his way is that we take our freedom and surrender it to him, choosing something deeper and more profound, which is obedience. Let me finish with the second half of that Bonhoeffer passage: "Who stands fast? Only the man whose final standard is not his reason, his principles, his conscience, his freedom, or his virtue, but who is ready to sacrifice all this when he is called to obedient and responsible action in faith and in exclusive allegiance to God."

A theology of suffering

Wendy: Amazing. After you, I'm talking to Anna from Open Doors about people with very restricted freedoms. But I think many of those dear brothers and sisters in very dire situations really understand true freedom, don't they? True freedom is found in Christ.

Alister: Yes, and we need a good theology of suffering. The Western church is rather unique in church history, in that circumstances haven't made it easy for us to develop one. We live in the shadow of Christendom: having the levers of power, being in control, even, as a church, delighting in decadence. We don't generally know persecution. Go and live in northern Nigeria, where hundreds, thousands of Christians are being slaughtered. We need to come to grips with this. What's normal in scripture and through so much of church history is that suffering with Christ and for Christ turns out to be redemptive, profoundly meaningful, and prophetically powerful in breaking strongholds in people who watch the church live in this extraordinary way.

Wendy: And yet, here in Australia, we're not meant to seek out suffering. We're not looking to be martyrs. The Bible tells us to pray for those in authority so that we may live peaceful lives, so God wants us to relish the freedom we have. But that isn't our answer to life, and we need to be prepared for it not always being this way, and learn from our brothers and sisters. While we have this freedom, we have the challenge of not using it for our own laziness or our own adventures, but for God's purposes. So practically, Alister, how do we live in this relative freedom, knowing true freedom is found in the heart, and choose faith in Jesus rather than freeze or flight, individually and corporately?

A people on mission

Alister: Just one observation. Even as Paul is quick to talk about freedom, and the whole New Testament is about freedom in Christ, one of the favourite ways Paul and John, and maybe Peter too, describe themselves is as a slave. On the one hand they champion freedom, and on the other they're settled in describing themselves as willing slaves to the ministry Jesus has called them to. I think we need to ponder that deeply.

God has called us to mission, to make disciples, to finish the task. In Matthew 24, Jesus says the gospel will be preached to the ends of the earth, and then the end will come. We're fundamentally a people on mission, because God himself is on mission. So, as I guess I always do, I'd encourage people to press into the Lord, not just relationally, but by studying the life of Jesus and getting our noses into the word. He set a pattern for us in how he lived, how he gathered disciples, how he trained them, and how he sent them out in the power of the Spirit. That's what he calls us to. We have work to do.

If you're an individual Christian listening and thinking, "I can't relate to that. I've never brought anyone to Jesus. I've never been any good at telling people about the Lord. I'm absorbed in what I do, but I don't really bear any missional fruit," I'd say that's a problem. Recognise that God has better for you. Start asking the Holy Spirit for opportunities, for training, and for engagement with people who don't know him. The joy of seeing the spiritual lights come on for someone who doesn't know Jesus is very powerful. And if the church is doing that, I tell you what, it's going to raise hell. Everywhere the church does it, it does. And then we can have a different kind of conversation about suffering.

Wendy: I was in the park yesterday afternoon with my youngest granddaughter, and just being there with the other mums is an opportunity. That's a mission field. You have a mission field with your wife Gail and your children, but also through Power to Change. Is there something happening at Power to Change you can briefly share?

Alister: The thing I want to point people to is a program called My Friends. It's not our own invention. It's an amalgam of things. But it's a way of being trained to participate with the Holy Spirit in your normal everyday life: to open your life to people who don't know Jesus, to pray for them, care for them and share with them, building a bridge for the gospel, bringing people to Jesus, and training them to do likewise. Go to powertochange.org.au and look for My Friends, one word. There are other things, but that's a really tangible thing to grab as a starting point.

Wendy: That's great. And I'd encourage you to look for those opportunities in the park, with children and grandchildren. Talk to people. Just say hi, and it's amazing how conversations open up. Alister, it's always fabulous to talk to you. Thank you for joining us again on 20twenty, and I look forward to seeing you in person sometime.

Alister: Thanks for having me, Wendy. God bless you.

Get new posts by email

Essays and notes, sent when they're published. No spam, unsubscribe in one click.