11 min read
The panopticon effect
We behave differently when we know we're being watched, and a generation growing up with cameras always out is paying for it. Neil Johnson and I talk about cringe culture, shame, and the God who watches over us in love.
I joined Neil Johnson on 20twenty on Vision Christian Radio on 6 May 2026. This is a lightly edited transcript of our conversation. You can listen to the full interview above.
Neil: What's driving behaviour in our secular, technological age? Some might ask why young people behave the way they do, but I'm happy to ask why we all behave the way we do. Mostly, we're on our best behaviour when we know someone's watching, and there's a term for that: the panopticon effect. When awkward or uncool behaviour is policed through viral mockery, you get what's called cringe culture. And younger generations now rely on AI to think, write and solve problems before they'll trust a parent, a teacher or a Christian leader. It may be that the biggest surveillance and enforcement tool ever is here right now, and younger generations are most at risk. Alister Cameron is back with us. He works with Power to Change, formerly Campus Crusade for Christ, and he's the Australian ambassador for the Finishing the Task initiative. Alister, we're in the deep end. Welcome back to 20twenty.
Alister: I've got my floaties on, Neil. I hope you have too.
A prison where you're always being watched
Neil: I have. You've been thinking about the ways young people use social media, and this might be the biggest danger of all the ones we've talked about. Where does this start in your thinking?
Alister: It starts with the gospel. It starts with understanding the times we live in and what God would have us do, like the sons of Issachar in scripture. That's always on my heart: to understand this moment in history, particularly for the younger generations, for whom I feel a tremendous sense of responsibility. I'm a father of Gen Z children, and by Gen Z we roughly mean 15 to 30-year-olds. We have a responsibility to make the gospel intelligible, powerful and transformative in their lives, as with everybody.
But maybe this story starts with me visiting Port Arthur. It took me a while to get around to Tasmania, but I visited the Port Arthur settlement. In more recent years it's remembered for horrific reasons, but even back then it was a pretty scary place. It was a prison colony, and as we toured the different prison arrangements, we came to one called a panopticon. I'd never heard the term before.
Panopticon is from the Greek, meaning able to see everything. Jeremy Bentham, a philosopher of the late 1700s and early 1800s, came up with the idea of a prison where the cells are arranged like slices of a pizza, with a watchtower in the middle. The prisoners never know when they're being watched and when they're not. They only know that at any moment they could be. That had a powerful psychological effect on their compliance. They fell into line because they didn't want to be punished, and they could never be sure they weren't being watched.
Neil: What a wonderful illustration. Everyone's under surveillance from that watchtower. And for the first time we have digital natives, Gen Z and Gen Alpha, growing up with that device in their hand almost like an extra limb. They're growing up in a digital panopticon, a state of permanent visibility. How do you describe the effects on young people?
When everyone is filming, nobody dances
Alister: We're thinking in psychological terms here: what this does to a person's sense of self and to the way they engage socially when the cameras are always out. Let me illustrate with an article I came across in Melbourne's Herald Sun while researching this topic. A writer observing Melbourne's dance culture says Melbourne has lost her shuffle. Nobody's dancing anymore. Why? Because you can't dance like nobody's watching when everyone is watching. With phones and cameras out, cringe culture is rampant among Gen Z, and clubgoers blame social media, and everyone filming every moment on the dance floor, for the loss of freedom.
If that's true of the dance floor, is it also true of the high school classroom and playground? Of the church youth group? Sociologists observe a marked difference in the younger generation. They've psychologically absorbed the idea that one mistake, one moment where they do something cringe, is locked in forever on a permanent digital record that never gets erased.
Neil: A kind of public shaming because you were filmed on the dance floor, or doing whatever in the school grounds. A perceived failure: "I didn't measure up, someone will criticise me, so I need to conform." That's a powerful way of thinking about a major structural change in how young people behave.
The algorithm replaced God
Alister: It is. And there's a parallel for us to think about, Neil: high-control religious environments. For those who came from, or nearly came from, a cultic religious background, here's a quote I came across: if this feels eerily familiar to anyone who grew up in a high-control religious environment, that's not a coincidence. The mechanics are the same: constant self-examination, fear of moral contamination, public shaming and the threat of exile. Only the authority figure has changed. "God" was replaced by the algorithm. Confession was replaced by screenshots in the group chat.
Try to imagine what that's like. You're on the dance floor, or in the high school playground, and someone videos you. One still from that video makes you look silly because you've got a dumb expression on your face. It gets spread across Instagram, Snapchat and the rest, and then it's talked about in the classroom. Why? Because bullies do that. Silly people do silly things. That's always existed in youth culture. You and I will remember it from our own youth, Neil. But what's different is that the moment can last forever, and social shaming can feel worse than death.
Neil: I'm thinking of the old 1984 idea of Big Brother, that someone's always watching. We always thought some kind of authority would be enforcing conformity. But here it's your friends, all your friends on social media, enforcing conformity to the standards of this world.
Alister: That's right. And think of the anxiety that comes with it. The fruit for many young people, and adults too, is self-censorship. "I could say something, I could act a certain way, I could put myself forward, but I'll hold back." So there's a move towards not speaking, not communicating, staying in your bedroom rather than going out.
Another aspect is performative behaviour: "I've got to work out what people want me to look like, what cool is, and then perform it. I don't necessarily believe it or understand it, but I need to perform in a prescribed way." Another is reduced spontaneity: a check in your spirit against expressing yourself naturally and freely, because you might land in that cringe space. And the result is chilled social interaction. A lot of young people would rather stay in their bedroom, in the digital domain, than venture out into the real social world. They don't feel very good at it, and it comes with risks that didn't used to exist, or not in the same way.
What this means for the church
Neil: So the panopticon effect is reshaping how young people relate to their friends. But it also has a major influence on the formation of moral values. Things we've thought of as good moral values, even biblically shaped ones, are getting twisted in all sorts of directions. How do you relate this to Christian values?
Alister: There's probably a lot more to say here than we can get to this morning, Neil. But one thing to consider is that a lot of who we are morally is shaped by our social lives, our interactions, the way we engage with others. So the church has a wonderful opportunity, starting with our own children, to put boundaries around the digital lives we live, as against our real lives.
There's something tremendously healthy about a well-functioning church community. Yes, there's youth hanging out with youth on a Friday night, but there's also that multi-generational social experience: putting the devices down and learning to relate to one another without that risk. Use your words, as parents say to their toddlers.
I have to laugh, Neil. My son's wife recently went into labour, and they had a baby. Ahead of time I'd said to him, "Please let me know." So he did. He sent me a message on X with just two little emojis. I'd failed to tell my dear Gen Z son to use his words, because he defaulted to what he knows best, which was digital communication of a rather obscure kind.
So we need to say to our own children, let alone the kids out in the world who aren't part of a church: this is what real relationship is. This is what real social engagement is. We need to put guardrails and boundaries around the digital stuff.
Watched in shame, or watched in love
Neil: That's very powerful. Alister, I can't help bringing in the idea we've all grown up with if we grew up in church life: God is watching over you. He's everywhere present, he's all-knowing, he knows the number of hairs on our head. He knows our behaviour. But there's a difference between that and social media watching over us, with our peers judging every move. One of the motivations of the social media panopticon is shame. God's motivation is love. How do you think about that difference, when we talk about God being the one who watches over us?
Alister: This is the remarkable and beautiful message of the Christian gospel. Jesus brings freedom. Jesus speaks a word against shame. There's liberty in him, freedom in him. You connect with God by the Holy Spirit, you experience his love, and suddenly you realise that so many of the things that mattered don't matter anymore.
I don't know about you, Neil, but that's my personal story. I came out of a childhood where I experienced a lot of shame and a lot of complications, and there were days I couldn't get out of bed. But as I pressed into God, and as the love of God washed over me, it was like Paul, who said, "I don't even judge myself." There comes a moment when you believe what Jesus says, and that love releases you from the things that used to matter. What an exciting thing it is to see people grow in Jesus and walk away from the need for affirmation from other people. I don't know that we'll all become like Paul, who could say, "I care very little what people think of me." That's remarkable. But that's the trajectory in Jesus.
Neil: We so often hear the criticism that Christians are so judgmental, that God is the judge and he's watching me every moment. But what we've got with the social media panopticon is instant, ultimate judgment. In God you have a stable moral observer, with long-term accountability, who is gracious after our failures. The panopticon gives you multiple unstable observers watching your every move, instant judgment every time you do something cringe, and cancellation as what ultimately awaits you. Put those side by side and I know which one I'm choosing.
Alister: There's not much in it. You'd choose God, wouldn't you? And here's the word for young people who are searching. Jesus says, "I did not come to condemn the world, but to save it." Yes, you are being watched, but not in a digital panopticon. You're being watched by a Father who loves you, who wants to free you from the things that bind you, and to introduce you to his Son and the life that's available in Jesus. You're being watched because God can't take his eyes off you. He loves you, and he wants to introduce you to abundant life. That's a message of hope. I hope and pray, Neil, that even this morning we can each find ways to bring that message of life to people caught in the digital panopticon, who need to find freedom in Jesus.
Neil: Somehow we need to wrestle, prayerfully, with how to break free from the digital panopticon and align with what you could call a godly panopticon: God watching over us, gracious and faithful, leading us into a quality of life rather than into the shame that comes from social media. What a great topic.
You can hear Alister has a heart for young people. Visit powertochange.org.au, where there's the wonderful My Friends resource, and finishingthetask.com to find out where Australia fits in the mission to win the world for Christ. Alister Cameron, always such a pleasure. Thanks for joining us on 20twenty.
Alister: Pleasure, Neil.


