Victorian Government abuses a child to save a smoker?

A Victorian anti-smoking ad shows a small boy who seems genuinely lost and terrified. I don't think he was acting, and that disturbs me.

Happy to be told I'm making something out of nothing, but this video disturbs me.

It's a television ad, currently airing in Victoria, Australia, as part of a Government anti-smoking campaign. Until the end you have no idea what it's promoting, and frankly, it could have been anti-speeding, anti-unsafe-sex, anti-anything.

But my point is, there is no way this poor kid could have been acting. No, I have to assume he was made to think he was lost, and the camera crew was hidden from him. That's pretty mean.

Is that overstepping some line? You decide.

From the official media release:

Quit Victoria's Executive Director, Ms Fiona Sharkie said despite being devoid of graphic images of disease-ridden bodies the new campaign, airing from Sunday night, would still pack a huge emotional punch.

"This new campaign depicts very powerfully the personal and emotional impact that smoking-caused illnesses have on the lives of smokers' families, particularly their children."

Ms Sharkie says the campaign was developed in the context of data showing approximately 5% of the Victorian adult population have children 12 years or younger and are current smokers, which corresponds to approximately 211 273 smokers.

"This campaign may be confrontational but we don't apologise for that. If we can get just one of those 211 273 smokers to quit and spare one young Victorian the grief of losing a parent to smoking then our job is done."

(As a side note, you have to admit Pat Lennox and Ben Green are a powerhouse creative duo, over at Campaign Palace, having already come up with some cool stuff for the same client, but I digress...)

What do you think?

Get new posts by email

Essays and notes, sent when they're published. No spam, unsubscribe in one click.