What is the point of Christmas?

If humanity had never sinned, would Jesus still have come? Neil Johnson and I jump into the deep end on the incarnation, our adoption as sons and daughters of God, and why Christmas is bigger than a rescue mission.

Listen to the interview20twenty · Vision Christian Radio

I joined Neil Johnson on 20twenty on Vision Christian Radio on 10 December 2025. This is a lightly edited transcript of our conversation. You can listen to the full interview above.

Neil: We're digging a little deeper today, asking constructive questions like: what's the point of Christmas? Alister Cameron works with Power to Change, formerly Campus Crusade for Christ, and he's back with us. Alister, welcome back to 20twenty.

Alister: Thank you, Neil. Great to be with you and the whole Vision family this morning.

Would Jesus have come anyway?

Neil: We sometimes talk about the shallow end and the deep end on this program, and I think we're jumping straight into the deep end. I hope we don't lose listeners, so listen in carefully. You've been wrestling with this question: if humans had been perfect and never sinned, would Jesus still have come in the flesh, the creator stepping into creation? Lead us in some thoughts.

Alister: What a fun place to start! Some of you are thinking, "What on earth?" But there's some logic to it. Jesus is the reason for the season, right? Christmas is about the incarnation, God coming in the flesh. And I had what I thought was a silly question. To be clear, I don't know that we can ultimately answer it. But it focuses our attention on questions that are theological on the one hand, and substantive and meaningful on the other.

We know Jesus came to save us from our sins. But is that the only reason he came? Different people will answer that differently. One way to focus the question is to ask: if Adam and Eve, and humanity after them, had remained perfect in God's eyes and never sinned, would there have been any purpose to Jesus coming?

All I'll say is this. The longer I've thought about the resurrection life Jesus invites us into, the more convinced I've become. As Christians we talk about the life in the Holy Spirit we have today as the first fruits, because in the glory to come, in the resurrection life, God promises us something remarkable. And I've come to the conviction that what Adam and Eve had was never as good as what we're promised in heaven.

So I'm of the school of thought that says that, even in theory, Jesus and the Father, in the power of the Spirit, planned our adoption in eternity, before time. As Paul writes in Ephesians 1, we were predestined for adoption as sons and daughters. And I believe the fullness of that adoption required Jesus becoming one of us, so that we could become, not God, but godlike, with him for eternity. That's a lot to unpack, but I've chewed on it a lot, because I don't want to take anything away from the glory and majesty of what God has done in becoming one of us.

Neil: I love being in the deep end with you, because you're talking about God's intentions in the first place. We can tell the Christmas story and interpret it in light of scripture and of our sinful nature, but you're taking us further back, to God's intentions before sin ever entered humanity.

More than a rescue mission

Alister: Yes, and it comes back to how we often share the gospel. Many of us have learned the basic narrative: God created us with good things in mind, then we sinned, and Jesus came to fix the problem. Nobody's challenging that. But there's another narrative that has to run alongside it: that God, Father, Son and Spirit, in all the Trinitarian glory we believe in, chose to create us. He didn't have to. And he created us, from the beginning, for adoption in Christ into his eternal life.

Then yes, redemption comes in. We need to be redeemed. Our lives weren't acceptable to God. We live under the tyranny of death, the fear of death, and sin, and Jesus saves us from that. He's our Saviour and we need saving. But we were also always in the heart and purposes of God, predestined for adoption as his children. Those two things need to sit together.

I don't think it's the full gospel, the full good news story, if the only story is that Jesus was brought into the picture, becoming human to save us, wonderful as that is. I sometimes fear that when we present the gospel, particularly at Christmas, and focus on Jesus coming as a baby, it becomes only a story about us needing saving. It should also be a story about God creating humanity because he loves us and wants us in his family. That was always his purpose, in all eternity.

Adopted, and redeemed

Neil: I'm following you, and I hope listeners are keeping up. There's redemption: here comes the Saviour, born in a stable and laid in a manger, who grows up, dies on the cross and rises again. And you're bringing alongside it God's intention to adopt us into his family, and his good pleasure in doing that, as described in Ephesians 1, from about verse 5. This adoption has some amazing benefits that we often just pay lip service to.

Alister: Let's read it for listeners: "He predestined us for adoption to sonship through Jesus Christ, in accordance with his pleasure and will, to the praise of his glorious grace, which he has freely given us in the One he loves." That's Paul's first thought. Then his second: "In him we have redemption through his blood, the forgiveness of sins." You can't separate them. But it's worth suggesting that one is the forethought, the big thought, and the next is the necessary thought in view of our failure.

I love the idea of the vicarious humanity of Christ: he lives the life we were supposed to live, so that he can be our high priest. Can I focus on the high priest for a moment? In the Old Testament the high priest has two functions. He represents God to the people, carrying out God's purposes towards them, pronouncing forgiveness and so on. And he represents the people to God, presenting acceptable sacrifices, and in doing so he separates the people from their sin. Jesus does that once and for all, as the Lamb who takes away the sin of the world. He's our perfect high priest because he lived our life perfectly, so he can represent humanity, be the second Adam who undoes the first Adam's sin, and invite us into the life of God.

The thing that blows my mind, Neil, and we don't often think this, is that right now there's a human in the Godhead. Right now there's a human in heaven. So in God's purposes, established in eternity before any act of creation, Jesus was already committing to the Father: "Yes, Abba. I'll alter myself forever to become a human being," with all the limitations that come with that, not least emptying himself of his divine prerogatives for a season to enter the fullness of our experience. But it doesn't end there. He's still a human being. He lived a perfect life for us, and that life continues in heaven. How do you and I know we're destined for heaven? How do we know it works? Because there's a human there now.

An inheritance

Neil: It's amazing, and you're probably inspiring a bunch of listeners to go to Bible college, because this is what you grapple with around the lunch table with other students. You're talking about adoption as sons and daughters of God, and the fact that God takes pleasure in it. Often we think of God with a big stick, the punishing God. But here is God taking pleasure in adopting us, and redeeming us by sacrificing his own life in love: moving us from slavery under sin to sonship, with all its benefits, including an inheritance of God's riches and authority. Have you thought about the benefits of being a willing adoptee into the family of God?

Alister: Absolutely. Why did Jesus become human? We've investigated that a little theologically, but there are all kinds of benefits. In the Eden story, God gave humanity dominion over creation, a kind of lordship under his ultimate lordship, and Adam gave it away through sin. So until Jesus hung on the cross and won the final victory in death, Satan had a legal claim to the keys he held over death, the fear of death, sin and so on. Then Jesus, as it were, goes to hell and says, "I'll take those keys, thank you very much. I'm the perfect Adam, bringing things back into the order God determined."

Satan's still around, but whatever the powers of darkness are doing, they're illegal squatters on land they don't own. They use deception, lies and manipulation to get what they want, because they can't legally have it. That can work very well for them. But it means that, as humanity, we have a certain dominion restored to us. No time for it today, but I think that's a very interesting theme to explore.

Another is that Jesus brings "many sons and daughters to glory", as Hebrews 2 says. We're the fruit of Jesus' rescue mission. In his high priestly prayer in John 17, Jesus tells the Father he hasn't lost a single one of those the Father gave him, referring to the disciples, but we're in that number too.

I could keep going, but there are so many themes that come back to our benefit. Can I add one more?

Neil: Please do.

Alister: I think it's absolutely remarkable that after 2000 years of Christianity, of roughly 2.6 billion Christians, by best estimates, probably fewer than 60 million claim to be Christian without holding an orthodox Trinitarian view of God. That blows my mind. One of our remarkable inheritances as Christians today is that orthodoxy is completely pervasive across the church, with very little heresy or nonsense around the core questions of who God is and who Jesus is. That's an extraordinary inheritance, and proof that the Holy Spirit is real and at work.

Sealed by the Spirit

Neil: Let's personalise this as we draw the threads together: what does it mean for me? There's the incarnation, Jesus born in a stable on Christmas Day. It's a beautiful story, and a messy, untidy, dirty setting for the Son of God to be born. And then there's the giving of the Holy Spirit, sealing everything we've talked about: redemption and adoption. What does the sealing of the Holy Spirit do for our identity, our acceptance into God's family, and our expectation that God has good plans for us, that we're not here by accident?

Alister: Wonderful question. If you study the life of Jesus, you find that to some degree he set aside some of his specifically divine attributes and leaned entirely on the Holy Spirit. He had the Holy Spirit from conception. Yes, there's the baptism with the Spirit descending like a dove, but Jesus had the Holy Spirit his whole life. He was fully God and fully man, and in his full humanity he relied on the Holy Spirit. That shows us how to live the Christian life. There's such depth for us in encountering God by the power of the Holy Spirit as we read scripture, take part in Christian community and walk with God.

My encouragement to Christians today would be to read the book of Acts, for example. Look at how the Holy Spirit shows up at that first Pentecost and how he transforms the lives of Christians. Jesus said it was better for him to go to the Father, because then he could send the Paraclete, the companion, to be with us. That's another massive, deep well, Neil. But in the life of Jesus we have the archetypal example of walking with the Father in the power of the Spirit. Whatever we can do this season to reflect on that, and to lean into it as we tell people the story of Jesus when the opportunity comes, will be tremendously encouraging and fruitful.

Neil: So whether you're a new believer or a long-time believer who's stayed in the shallow end, think about what this means for your walk with God, perhaps contemplating 2026: a family identity, accepted into God's family, with his power and authority, heading for the victorious destiny he's already planned, including an inheritance. We're working out our salvation, living towards where God is leading us. We've seen the beginning of the story and we know the end, and somewhere in the middle, here we are. Who knew Christmas was so deep?

You can connect with Alister at powertochange.org.au. Power to Change is part of the Cru and Campus Crusade family of ministries around the world, in schools, colleges and universities and well beyond. Alister, very quickly, this is our last catch-up for the year. Anything special happening at your place for Christmas?

Alister: The special thing is that I'm a grandfather twice over, with a third on the way, and the eldest turns one between Christmas and New Year. So I get Christmas, New Year and my granddaughter's first birthday. I'm happy as a clam.

Neil: Congratulations, and God's richest blessing on you and the team at Power to Change. I look forward to more great, deep conversations in the new year. Thanks for your updates through the year, and for today's on 20twenty.

Alister: Thank you, Neil. Every blessing to you as well.

Get new posts by email

Essays and notes, sent when they're published. No spam, unsubscribe in one click.