Why we should not predict the rapture

A South African pastor's "billion per cent certain" rapture date went viral, and people sold cars and rewrote wills. Neil Johnson and I talk about date-setting, spiritual group-think online, and some guardrails for reading the end times.

Listen to the interview20twenty · Vision Christian Radio

I joined Neil Johnson on 20twenty on Vision Christian Radio on 15 October 2025. This is a lightly edited transcript of our conversation. You can listen to the full interview above.

Neil: We're back with Alister Cameron from Power to Change. He's been thinking about something in play right now: preachers who keep setting dates for the rapture. With all the developments in the Middle East around Israel, there's lots of speculation about the end times, and some Christians become so consumed by the end-times angle on the headlines that their obsession leads to some awkward predictions. What do we make of preachers who set dates for the rapture? Alister, welcome back to 20twenty.

Alister: Great to be here, Neil. Thank you.

A billion per cent certain

Neil: There's a preacher from South Africa who's been setting dates in recent weeks. What's your impression of him?

Alister: We live in what I've previously described to you with the acronym VUCA: times of volatility, uncertainty, complexity and ambiguity. It's not surprising that when the heat gets turned up, people start looking for a fire escape. That's pretty normal in many circumstances of life.

So in June a man called Pastor Joshua Mhlakela, from South Africa, popped up on a YouTube channel predicting, "one billion per cent" certain, that the end of the world would come in late September. For whatever reason, and I put it down to the culture and the technology, it caught fire. Word got around and people got very worried. By 24–25 September there were over 321,000 TikTok posts. I'm not on TikTok, but there was a lot of "RaptureTok", as they called it.

We laugh, but it was quite consequential for some people. There were videos of people changing their wills to redirect things to non-Christian family members, because the Christians wouldn't be around. People sold their possessions. A man in Queensland sold his car and was very vocal about it on TikTok. People said goodbye to loved ones, including mothers saying goodbye to their toddlers. At least one mother handed her children over to child protective services because she wasn't going to be there. A staff member at KPMG thought, "I've got nothing to lose," and sent an all-staff email warning them about the end of the world and telling them to repent, which KPMG then had to deal with.

Needless to say, Neil, we're all still here. The 24th and 25th came and went. Then some people he was engaging with said, "You just got the calendar wrong. You used the Julian calendar instead of the Gregorian," or the other way around, I can never remember. They did some quick calculations and decided it was meant to be 6–7 October. Well, Neil, that's passed too, hasn't it?

Neil: It has. But he was a billion per cent sure. A hundred per cent would be enough! He said Jesus appeared to him in a dream and told him the date of his return. But any of us could have a dream. Here's someone with a pulpit and a YouTube channel announcing what he's a billion per cent sure of, and clearly he has followers who are very open to being manipulated by something that runs contrary to what scripture says about date-setting.

Alister: That's right, and he's not the first. Many of us remember Hal Lindsey's The Late Great Planet Earth and Tim LaHaye's Left Behind series. Some of us remember Harold Camping and his Family Radio network in 2011. He'd largely disappeared by 2012 and passed away the year after. Go back further and there's William Miller and the "Great Disappointment" of 1844, and further still. Some of these predictions come as a "word of the Lord". Some come from numerology, calendars and complex calculations based on Old Testament apocalyptic writings. People will always pop up doing this. What interests me more is the tendency of the average Christian to get carried away with it, because that can have very serious pastoral implications.

Neil: So he set dates for September, decided the calendar must be wrong, and reset them for October. I think he has a bit of egg on his face. But some of his followers are pushing it all the harder. What's the latest?

Alister: Brace yourselves, everybody, and hold on to something, because some followers have worked out that there's another thing called the Enochian calendar. I dare say they'll find a Mayan and an Aztec calendar soon enough. I don't know enough about the Book of Enoch and its calendar to explain it with any sophistication, Neil, but I'll tell you this: they've set the date for tomorrow, the 16th or the 17th depending on where you are in the world. So if I'm back in a fortnight, and God willing I would be raptured if I were a candidate, I suspect we'll still be around.

Neil: I don't think it's wrong to suspect we'll still be here in two weeks. And if the rapture did happen tomorrow, well and good. It doesn't change how we're supposed to live our lives, without obsessing over a date for Jesus' return. There's plenty of scripture that says don't set dates. Anything come to mind?

How do we know what we know?

Alister: Absolutely. Jesus says only the Father knows the day and the hour. That's a very straightforward instruction from Jesus. If Jesus himself, who sits at the Father's right hand, didn't know, why would we? That's a pretty fundamental question.

I've got a few thoughts that I hope will help with how we approach the broad question of what the Bible says about the end times, and how to hold the right posture. The first is a bit deep, but I won't go too far. There's a branch of philosophy called epistemology: how do we know what we know? How do I know the chair I'm sitting on is really there? Silly philosophical questions. But very simply, as Christians we need to be careful not to end up with what you might call a mystical epistemology, where we decide that because of some supernatural experience, we suddenly know something we didn't know before.

That happens a lot. With this pastor, many people didn't believe him at first. But then they saw other people on YouTube, TikTok and Instagram saying, "I wasn't sure whether to believe it, but then God confirmed it to me in a different way." Then another person had an experience where God told them too. Multiple completely mystical, ungrounded "spiritual" experiences end up acting with authority to convince people. That's a worry.

I understand the charismatic and Pentecostal world. I'm in that space. But when a bunch of people stand up and, in a reinforcing, confirming way, say "God told me too", that doesn't mean you should just buy into it and say, "That settles it then." All those mystical experiences don't define what knowledge is.

Algorithms and accountability

Neil: Bring algorithms into this. When you watch a YouTube clip or whatever you're looking at on social media, the algorithm points you to everyone else commenting on the same thing. It's easy to become obsessed, because we're bombarded with things that reinforce our ideas. That can be good, but it can also be bad. In a digital age, algorithms put us in our own little thought bubbles that are hard to break out of.

Alister: Exactly. Take TikTok. The minute it knows you're interested in that kind of conversation, you're going to get all 321,000 rapture videos, and many of them aren't critical but supportive. So the question is: who do you give authority to speak into your life? How do you ground your convictions? God has placed us in Christian community and in accountable relationships. To wander off the reservation into TikTok land and start listening to voices saying, over and over, "Yes, God told me that too"? No. Stop that. It's not healthy.

Neil: A lot of people say social media has become their church. They're somehow disconnected from a local church, where a pastor preaches on Sunday and there are home groups where you rub shoulders with people and have conversations. Nothing wrong with online church, but if it's the only thing you do, you might be missing something.

Alister: Absolutely. We need to be grounded. If you live on a cattle station in the middle of nowhere, three hundred miles from anything, okay, maybe. But God has called us into the checks and balances and provisions of the Holy Spirit, to protect us. That's a protective function, a caring function, God's loving pastoral heart for us in placing us in community, and we walk away from it at our own risk.

There's also a danger that in some of these spaces, the minute you push back, the minute you say "I'm not sure that sits well with me", you're accused of being a mocker and a scoffer. It's almost mind control. It's almost cultish behaviour sometimes. In a long-term, loving community, God engineers lots of checks and balances so that kind of nonsense gets dealt with in a healthier way. Plus, of course, rigorous scriptural wisdom: good interpretation of scripture, and knowing how to apply the word of God properly.

Guardrails for reading the end times

Neil: So here we are, the day before someone has predicted the rapture. When we look at the end times and the apocalyptic imagery in the Bible, are there some rules you like to use? Where would you start?

Alister: I'll start with one word of wisdom. When it comes to eschatology, the end times, some of the best scholars in the world don't agree on the details. We have different views of the millennium, different views of the rapture, and different ways of reading Revelation, from very sincere, very godly people who are very skilled in Greek and Hebrew and the book of Daniel and so on. So just realise you're probably not going to get to the bottom of this better than someone else. With that, here are a few concluding points as I see them.

First, don't make, and don't believe, a prediction about the end of the world. Full stop. If someone comes out with dates and times for the end of the world, walk away. That's about 99 per cent of the wisdom right there.

Second, remember that the books of the Bible weren't written to us first. That's a simple point, but it means that when John writes Revelation, including seven letters to seven churches, those letters meant something to those churches. Before they mean anything to us, they had to mean something to the original readers. That's a really healthy way to come to scripture, because it stops us reading nonsense into things, even when we don't think it's nonsense.

Third, read a biblical book as a whole, for its overall meaning. When you come to Revelation, Daniel, Ezekiel, or any of the texts that tend to get used this way, read them as a whole. That will only get you so far, because you probably don't know the Hebrew and the Greek. So read other people's 30,000-foot view of what's going on. It often helps you see why people take a particular scripture and read something into it, and then, having seen the whole, realise you can't really do that.

Fourth, remember that Jesus himself told us not to bother. He said only the Father knows. Don't go there.

And last, on a really positive note, Neil, there's one wonderful thing the Lord says in Matthew 24:14: "This gospel of the kingdom will be preached in the whole world as a testimony to all nations, and then the end will come." So if someone asks me, "How will I know the end is near?", the biblical answer, Jesus' answer, is: when the gospel has been preached throughout the whole inhabited earth. Personally, Neil, that's where all my energy is focused. I want to see the gospel preached to the ends of the earth, because then I know that key insight from Jesus in Matthew 24 is ready to be fulfilled.

Sincere, but deceived

Neil: We need guardrails, because the second coming of Jesus is part of even the earliest ecumenical creeds. It's part of our faith, and we want to talk about it. But if you get this wrong it can lead to disillusionment. You might find the whole thing entertaining, but someone in your group or circle may get very disillusioned in their faith when you said the rapture was happening tomorrow, it didn't, and then you tried to backpedal and explain it. There are some big problems if you get this wrong, aren't there?

Alister: There are. You're right that people get disillusioned, and our churches and congregations end up with a pretty serious pastoral problem. Throughout scripture, certainly all through the Apostle Paul, the intention is that we come to the end times with hope, excitement and a sense of urgency. To the credit of some of the movements that have focused on the end times, there has been urgency: "We've got to get the gospel out. We've got to tell people about Jesus." But when you set a date and it fails, it's disillusioning.

What I generally see is that people are sincere, but deceived. So my heart for those of us who teach the word is that we treat the scriptures with the profound respect they deserve, and shy away from the predictive side of things, because I really don't believe that's where we're meant to land. But there's tremendous hope in what the Lord has in store for us, and the point is this: the gospel will be preached to the ends of the inhabited earth.

Neil: And Jesus is returning. He's promised to, and we take him at his word. We might speculate about how it happens, and whether or not there'll be a rapture, depending on your position, but that's too deep a conversation for the end of our time. Are there any resources people can access at Power to Change?

Alister: The one I always point people to, for very good reason, is a training program called My Friends, at powertochange.org.au/myfriends. You can do it online, and we run it in groups, offline and so on. It teaches people how to make sharing the gospel, and making disciples of people who don't know Jesus, real in their own lives. Everyday evangelism that's approachable and something you can build into your life: how to have the boldness and confidence to work with the Holy Spirit in winning people to Christ, building them up in the faith, and sending them out in the power of the Spirit to do the same. We work with whole congregations and with individuals. Our heart and vision is that right across Australia, people would be equipped, mobilised and excited, partnering with the Holy Spirit, finding people who don't know Jesus, engaging with them in a natural, lifestyle way, and seeing them come to faith.

Neil: Alister, I fully expect we'll be talking again in a couple of weeks. If not, we'll have been raptured away tomorrow! But let's keep a biblical view, with guardrails around how we understand Jesus coming back. And to reiterate what Alister said: run away when someone tries to set a date. Jesus himself said don't bother. Alister, you came up with the goods, and how relevant is that today? The Lord's blessing on you, and thanks for sharing your thoughts with us on 20twenty.

Alister: Thanks, Neil. Stay away from rapture talk, and have a great fortnight.

Get new posts by email

Essays and notes, sent when they're published. No spam, unsubscribe in one click.