22 min read
Young men in a feminised culture
If the church doesn't give our sons a vision of sacrificial manhood, the internet will give them a vision of selfish tribalism. Neil Johnson, listeners and I talk about why Gen Z men risk following the wrong leaders, and how the church can lead them home.
I joined Neil Johnson on 20twenty on Vision Christian Radio on 25 February 2026. This one was a longer, talkback episode, with listeners calling in. This is a lightly edited transcript of our conversation. You can listen to the full interview above.
Neil: It's no secret that Christian leaders have been concerned about what we've been calling a crisis of masculinity. Today we get a bit closer to where the rubber hits the road. As one leader put it, if the church doesn't give our sons a vision of sacrificial manhood, the internet will give them a vision of selfish tribalism. Our guest has been wrestling with why Gen Z men risk following the wrong leaders, and how the church can lead them home. Alister Cameron works with Power to Change, formerly Campus Crusade for Christ, and he's the Australian ambassador for the Finishing the Task initiative. Alister, welcome back to 20twenty.
Alister: Thank you, Neil. Great to be with you again.
A vision of sacrificial manhood
Neil: Let's start with that quote from a New York pastor, Jon Tyson: "If the church doesn't give our sons a vision of sacrificial manhood, the internet will give them a vision of selfish tribalism." Do you think that's happening?
Alister: Yes, I think it is, and it's a really good quote to start with, because the vision of manhood the church needs to present is Jesus, in all his humanity, all his divinity and all his glory. In every generation the church's challenge is to take the timeless truth of who God is and translate it into the cultural context of the moment, and we're doing that like every generation before us. For what it's worth, I'm hopeful and excited. The power and truth of God are there for us to take hold of. The Lord has commissioned us, and in Christ we can do these things. But we do need to stop and think about what this generation is wrestling with, and the particular challenges of presenting Jesus compellingly to them.
Nick Fuentes and the Groypers
Neil: These are challenging conversations, and there'll be young men listening who say, "What are you worried about? It's just someone I follow on the internet." I want to introduce a name and an organisation, without in any way glamorising either: Nick Fuentes, and the movement he leads, the Groypers. This is the sort of alternative young men might be looking for. It creates an opportunity for Christians, but it's also a threat. Give us your insights.
Alister: The Groypers are a movement, and even the name is based on a joke, a kind of silliness. That's very much the spirit of this young man, but he's not to be taken lightly. Some wiser voices have taken the time to study him and acknowledge that, as easily as he might be dismissed as ridiculous, he's being interviewed by people like Tucker Carlson and Piers Morgan, names listeners will know as significant figures in journalism.
He's in the US, potentially on the far right. Call him a live streamer and commentator. He's 27, turning 28 this year. He has a show, a bit like a podcast, called America First, where he's found his voice. He talks really well. He's very fast, very smart, very articulate. And he's captured the imagination of young white men, roughly 16 to 26-year-olds. So we're talking about Gen Z men, and because the internet is borderless, not just Americans but young men in Australia and Europe too.
He's tapping into disaffection. It's something of a protest movement, but he's also articulating a vision, a set of values, that look legitimate on the surface: themes of Christianity, of nationalism, of white pride in the face of a woke movement that says white is trash. But underneath it there's a toxicity that we as the church need to be aware of. He's been described as a digital Pied Piper, and he's captured the imagination of young men.
Neil: Jordan Peterson captured a male audience in a significant way, perhaps for some of the same reasons, and he's looking a bit older these days. Fuentes is no Jordan Peterson, but "digital Pied Piper" is an interesting way to describe how he magnetically attracts young men. He's funny and sharp and speaks the language of the internet fluently. That's dangerous when, at the core, the wrong message and the wrong image are being presented. And Aussie young men are following him too.
Alister: Yes, they are. In the US, the Groyper movement is big enough that it could swing the vote on the political right. The Trumps of this world need to pay attention, because if JD Vance ends up as the Republican candidate at the next election, he'll want these guys on side. So it's a significant group of people, and the question is why.
There's a lot of analysis. The more general way of putting it is a sense of alienation and marginalisation. As a young man today, discovering your masculinity and identity, there's a sense of coming up against a "woke" movement, if that's the right word, that says who you are isn't acceptable. The world wants to marginalise what earlier generations would have called normal behaviour: "What you are and how you operate isn't appropriate."
But of course, what happens with Fuentes is that he goes way too far. He's clearly misogynistic and says some dreadful things about women. He takes white nationalism almost to an extreme and starts to sound like a Ku Klux Klansman. He always does it in a sophisticated way, playing with humour and irony. I've noticed that when he's interviewed in a more formal setting he walks some of it back, as if it was just humour for effect, but young men don't always get that. And he's not the only one stirring up this discontent. Some people are really worried, because you don't want too many young men angry.
So the challenge for us as Christians is how to respond. If you don't have the right image of Jesus, of pre-eminent masculinity, God with us, the perfect image of God, then the alternatives look pretty scary.
Neil: And the Groyper movement is described by many as racist, nativist, fascist, sexist, homophobic, antisemitic and Islamophobic. Young men might feel drawn there because they feel at home in a space where nobody is calling them out or coming down hard on them.
The great feminisation
Neil: Have you been thinking through why this is happening, and why now?
Alister: There are a lot of whys. For discussion, I'd propose the ideas of a conservative commentator, Helen Andrews. She talks about what she calls "the great feminisation" as one way of explaining the woke phenomenon. She's a woman, and some kind of feminist in the midst of it all, but she argues that we live in a world where the balance has tipped in favour of women and a feminine way of doing things.
For example, look at the statistics on women in fields that were historically male-dominated, and in humanities and HR departments. That shapes the flavour of what it is to work in a corporate environment, and what's culturally acceptable for resolving conflict. Men tend to resolve conflict openly and then reconcile, whereas women tend to favour what she calls covert competition. You might end up in the same place, but how you get there is different.
So there's a cultural shift towards things being done in a way that suits women, because it's led by women. Now, that's an argument, and I'm not saying I fully agree with it. But young men feel they're being managed rather than mentored, squashed rather than encouraged. I don't think it's the whole explanation, but I do think it has some merit. Young men are growing up in a world that says no to a lot of what they feel is their natural self.
Jesus, the prototypical man
Neil: There's lots more to say, but let's come back to Jesus Christ, the perfect image of Almighty God, whom I know you describe as the prototypical man. As Christians we need to capture something of the masculinity of Jesus to counter the things that take our young men off on a tangent. Give us your thoughts.
Alister: Absolutely. I love this. In Jesus we have the image of perfect humanity, and certainly perfect masculinity. The church needs to re-engage with him in every generation and seek the inspiration of the Spirit to understand what it is to be men in this generation.
For example, I was meditating the other day on Matthew 5, the Sermon on the Mount, and the Beatitudes in particular. "He opened his mouth and taught them, saying: Blessed are the poor in spirit, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven. Blessed are those who mourn, for they shall be comforted. Blessed are the meek, for they shall inherit the earth." And so on.
I had a moment of clarity, and when I looked it up I realised I'm not the first person to think this: when Jesus gives the Beatitudes, he's describing himself. He's had 30 years of life, journeying with his Father, becoming who he is by the power of the Spirit, and he's describing himself. There's a poverty of spirit about Jesus. There's a spirit of mourning, lament and contemplation in Jesus. There's meekness: he says he's meek, and Paul calls him meek. "Blessed are those who hunger and thirst for righteousness." That's Jesus. Blessed are the merciful, and Jesus is merciful. Blessed are the pure in heart, the peacemakers, the persecuted. Among other things, Jesus is describing himself, which is to say: you're blessed when you come to me, when you experience me more deeply and I rub off on you.
I don't know that many men read the Beatitudes and think, "Wow, that's a beautiful, profound description of masculinity." But it is. So in every generation we need to come back to Jesus and say, "Lord, what is it to be more like you, particularly as men?"
Listeners call in
Neil: Let's take some calls. Mick is in Nambucca Heads, New South Wales.
Mick: Thanks, Neil. Two points. Back in creation, the woman's desire would be for her husband. We've always taken that as desire for a husband, but the word also carries the sense of wanting to dominate or override him. So women do test their partners to see whether they're worthy of leading them, and that's why the Lord said to Adam, "You shall rule over her." That can be distorted in all sorts of ways. And on Matthew 5: those words go back to Isaiah 61, and Isaiah 60 and 65. The end of Isaiah is all about the messianic kingdom that would come in Christ, and that's what Jesus is referring to. We have to be careful not to read ourselves into the meek and those who mourn. Yes, we do have to do those things as men, but it's best to get the original meaning from the old covenant: Israel was failing, and Isaiah 61 is what Christ quoted when he turned up.
Alister: Both points well made, Mick. Thank you. I agree there's the possibility of women supplanting men. But here I'm trusting the body of Christ to confront those things and to present to young men, as well as young women, an image that is interesting, compelling and godly. That's a challenge for every generation. And on Isaiah, you're absolutely right. I'm not going there today, but that's spot on for exegesis.
Neil: Peter is in Eltham, New South Wales.
Peter: Really important conversation. I can see how the church has perhaps allowed a feminisation, albeit unconsciously. I wonder whether the church experience for many young men is a bit too feminised. The emphasis on praise and worship is so important, but young men want to get their hands on something, get practical, get out into the community and have an adventure.
Alister: Peter, I guess it depends on which church you're talking about. Interestingly, in the UK people talk about a "quiet revival", more than here, and there's significant evidence that young Gen Z men are coming back to church in numbers that well outweigh young women of the same age. The question is why. There's definitely a sense that they're looking for something substantial and meaningful, something that won't be here today and gone tomorrow. There's such an ephemeral quality to everything online and digital. There's always the question, "Is this really real? Will it be here tomorrow?" So the older something is, the more substantial it feels.
Many are returning to Orthodox, Catholic or very traditional, very "old" expressions of church, and I think that has a lot to do with the confidence that if something's been around that long, it must mean something. There's more to it than that, but that's a whole area to dissect. As for the feminine aspect, I think that comes down to the particular traditions in question.
Neil: Alex is in Melbourne.
Alex: The Beatitudes, as Alister said, describe the good qualities of Jesus, because they're God's qualities, and Jesus is conveying them to us. We shouldn't confuse the dispensations. At the moment Jesus is our Saviour, but he's coming back as the judge. So for now, his qualities as Saviour are what we need, so we can be light to the world.
Alister: I can only agree with Alex on that one.
A king worth following into battle
Neil: Here's another quote: "These young men aren't looking for a polite Jesus. They're looking for a king worth following into battle." We're clearly pointing to Jesus Christ as the pre-eminent masculine model. Give us your thoughts.
Alister: That's absolutely right, Neil. In every generation, young men are looking for the ultimate vision of masculinity to follow. I don't have it verbatim, but there's an old story of a man recruiting young men for an expedition overseas, to futures unknown. He put an ad in the paper, perhaps The Times of London, saying something like: future uncertain, risk of death high. An extraordinary sales pitch you'd think nobody would answer. He was swamped with young men looking for something bigger than themselves. I think it's in the spirit of most, if not all, young men to aspire to something great, and we have the fulfilment of that aspiration in the person of Jesus, if we'll present him faithfully. That's the challenge in every generation.
The problem is that you have a young man like Nick Fuentes, and others like him. In fact, the internet has numerous people today who claim the name of Jesus, as Nick does. He says he's a Catholic, and a virgin keeping himself for marriage, so he has some of the outward markers. But so often, people who claim a Christian faith online then, from our perspective at least, muck it up. There are a lot of lies and half-truths out there. So the challenge is for the church to stand up and articulate biblical truth, wrapped up in community, belonging and meaning, in a way that actually draws young men away from the half-truths towards what's real.
A crisis of meaning, and false prophets
Neil: Some say there's a crisis of meaning. We've talked about the quiet revival, and young men gravitating towards church, looking for meaning in the meaninglessness that's so pervasive in our society. But doesn't that also give rise to what we as Christians would call false prophets? You could almost classify Nick Fuentes as a false prophet at this point.
Alister: That's right. We know the human heart is wired for meaning. There are different ways of saying it, like the "God-shaped hole" in the heart, an idea often traced back to Augustine and Pascal. There's a very healthy, burgeoning self-help movement online. Young men are drawn to the likes of Jordan Peterson, who tell them to clean their room, go to the gym, save for a house, maybe be a bit of a trad man and marry a trad woman, and go back to some older values. And they do all those things. But then the question is: why? Beyond the cosmetics, beyond the behaviour change and the self-help, there's that deeper question of why, and Christianity provides the narrative that the surface-level stuff doesn't reach.
They're also looking for proper moral grounding. Humans aren't just about meaning but about morals, and a lot of that is lacking. People can tell you what to do, but not why, or what's right and wrong about it. The church can. So there's clearly a limit to how far someone like Nick can go. I'm very excited when I hear reports of young men coming to church, because it's almost proof positive that self-help isn't enough, and they have some idea of where to go.
Neil: Let's take another call. Vanessa is in the Blue Mountains.
Vanessa: With love and respect, I think masculinity has cost a lot in our culture. I'm talking about honour, integrity, courage, loyalty, bravery, prudence, service and sacrifice. I have a 19-year-old son, a wonderful, very humble personality, and he searches for these masculine virtues, and I see his group of young men doing that too. I think there's some pushback against the over-feminising of virtues, because men and women have different qualities. It's in Ephesians 5:33 and 1 Peter 3:1–2, and throughout the Bible. If churches can appeal to the masculinity of young men the way Jesus showed it, and there are amazing examples of young men in the Bible showing his virtues...
Alister: Thank you, Vanessa. That's a really excellent contribution. We shouldn't be afraid of this. I'm not suggesting it's exclusively a male thing, but young men need to learn about virtues. They need to see them in the face of Christ, and they need to see them in older men. So there's mentoring, and a generation of fathers who sometimes need to stand in for a father who either wasn't there or wasn't good enough. And they need to be better than a lot of the internet examples of fathers, who often lead with something that looks like virtue but doesn't deliver the substance.
Safe third places for men
Neil: Those virtues Vanessa mentions, honour, prudence and sacrifice: if churches become too feminised, how does a man display that masculinity in church life? Let me put you on the spot, Alister. Do men in church need to change in some way?
Alister: I think we need to lean into who we are and find creative expressions for it. There's a famous book by Robert Putnam called Bowling Alone, which some listeners will remember. He points out that the social structures of society are hollowing out. The idea of someone going ten-pin bowling on their own would have been ridiculous in the fifties, but it happens now, because of the decline of local pubs, sports clubs and community hubs. Men getting together in meaningful ways to do blokey things in a blokey way, with a Christian expression to it, I'm not suggesting anything less, has hollowed out.
So young men today are looking for safe third places, outside home and work, where they can belong and find purpose, and the church is immediately an option. So here's my question for listeners this morning: what does it look like when a young man walks into your church? What options does he have to gather with men and to see, not just hear or be told about, a different vision of manhood?
Neil: A lot of churches have a men's group, and sometimes you turn up and the older men are there but the younger men aren't. There's a disconnect, and some responsibility falls on the older men to engage the younger ones, because that's where you have those heart-to-heart conversations. And with an absence of fatherhood, the men in our churches need to be exemplary fathers, not just in their own families but across the congregation. The people we appoint as leaders and elders, and "elder" has a fatherhood image to it, need to carry those masculine images, don't they?
Alister: Yes. There's a public version of that, and then there's what it looks like for men to come alongside young men personally. If you're a father with a teenage or young adult son, you've got it in spades, and I invite you to lean into that. If not, perhaps you're a grandad now with some spare time. The church needs to explore what making disciples looks like: older men coming alongside younger men, teaching them to pray, to read the Bible, to engage with Jesus in different ways, maybe to budget, to be responsible in life. Cleaning their room is probably a reasonable point! We need to get very practical. I'm sometimes at risk, Neil, of being too theoretical and living in the world of ideas, particularly on your program, but there's a moment to get very practical. I don't have all the answers, but it's a rich area to explore.
Good role models
Neil: Over some decades there was a real push for men to get in touch with their feminine side, and perhaps in church life men were more able to do that. Maybe now young men need encouragement to get in touch with their masculine side, with role models, and not Superman and Batman, but Jesus, the pre-eminent image of manhood. We've talked about a bad example in Nick Fuentes. Are there some good role models you can point listeners to, apart from yourself, of course?
Alister: There definitely are. It's not wrong to point to someone like Jordan Peterson. He hasn't been around much for a while, bless him in his illness. But one man I've come across, as have others, has appeared in places like Joe Rogan's show: Wes Huff, Wesley Huff. Some listeners will recognise the name. He's Canadian, and he actually used to work for my organisation, Campus Crusade, or Power to Change as it's also called in Canada. He's moved on from there and his focus is apologetics. He's a Bible scholar and he really knows his stuff. He'll do three hours on Joe Rogan, no problem, and get into the nitty-gritty. But he also has a beautiful way of presenting himself. He's a bit older, in his thirties, and he's married. And I think it's hilarious, because he's this muscly, super-fit guy, and in his spare time he's a samurai swordsman. I kid you not. There are videos of him on Instagram taking a break from work and swinging his sword around, very skilfully. Here's someone coming right into the face of young people and saying not "look at me", but establishing the credibility of the Christian faith, of Jesus and of scripture. I think that's wonderful, and there are more like him.
Neil: Look up Wes Huff. You might be surprised. We're running out of time, so a couple of quick calls. Glenn is in Parramatta.
Glenn: I think young men are turning back to Christianity because they're searching for connection. It goes back to the gospel story and original sin, where connection was broken, and Jesus shows a way to restore it. The way Jesus discipled his followers is an example: everyone needs three or four close friends to talk through all kinds of issues with, like Peter, James and John, then a wider circle, like the twelve, and then a bigger circle, the rest of his followers. I've recently come out of rehab over the last three years, and I work as a peer worker in alcohol and other drugs. Even men in elite parts of the armed forces would rather run off a mountain than face personal issues and emotions. So it helps to have someone who can be a samurai warrior but also show the softer side of dealing with emotions, because a lot of people aren't growing up having to deal with them. They grow up too fast, or escape having to deal with anxiety and stress.
Alister: I'll take that largely as a comment, Glenn, and I agree.
Neil: We need to find a well-rounded manhood. Thank you, Glenn. One more quick call. Kate is in Queensland.
Kate: I wanted to pick up what you said about elders in the church. Fatherlessness is a big issue in our society, as is abuse in families, which causes family breakdown. I have two sons, one a teenager and one a young adult. There's so much opportunity in churches for men, grandfathers, older men, fathers, to come alongside young men. I prayed about that for many years for my sons, and unfortunately it never happened, and neither of them is currently walking with the Lord. It's a real heart cry for me as a mum, and I know for a lot of other mums across Australia: for the men of the church to step up and be men of Christ.
Neil: Wonderful, Kate. It's almost an ache, isn't it, when you have sons and you want them to find masculine father figures in church. Alister, we have to call an end here. Is there anything you've written, or are working on, that listeners could read to build on this?
Alister: There may be, Neil. I'm constantly working on different things. In general I'd point people to powertochange.org.au. We have a program called My Friends, about opening ourselves up to the opportunities the Lord gives us to share the gospel and connect with people who don't know Jesus. It's a general starting point, but it's really valuable. And the sober note we're ending on today, Neil, is really important. Young men don't always know how to speak about what's going on inside, and a lot of the Father's heart here is to give them opportunities to do that. For some of us, a program like My Friends could be a bridge-building lesson or two in making those heart connections.
Neil: It's a good program, and we've spoken about it on 20twenty a time or two. You can also connect with Alister through finishingthetask.com. Alister, great conversation today. I really appreciate you, and look forward to talking again very soon.
Alister: Thank you, Neil.


