13 min read
Why are so many young people questioning the Holocaust?
Surveys show a growing number of young people are unsure the Holocaust happened. Neil Johnson and I talk about why memory fades after three generations, how distortion spreads, and how families and churches can pass the truth on.
I joined Neil Johnson on 20twenty on Vision Christian Radio on 22 April 2026. This is a lightly edited transcript of our conversation. You can listen to the full interview above.
Neil: Something quite disturbing today. A number of studies show a rise in uncertainty among young people about the historical fact of the Holocaust: that six million Jews died under the Nazi regime in World War II. Why is a gap developing in knowledge of one of the most important facts of the past hundred years, and how does a distortion like that develop and spread like a virus? Alister Cameron is back with us. He works with Power to Change, formerly Campus Crusade for Christ, and he's the Australian ambassador for the Finishing the Task initiative. Alister, welcome back to 20twenty.
Alister: Thank you, Neil. Good to be with you.
Where this showed up
Neil: This is being framed as Gen Z Holocaust revisionism. Where did you pick up that this was sweeping through young people?
Alister: Oh gosh, Neil, I don't want to admit this, but one of my sons, a Gen Z-er, asked me some very odd questions on exactly this subject recently. Another friend of mine, from a German background, has a son at a Christian school, from the very youngest end of that generation, who's been asking whether it really happened.
You'll recall we spoke a few weeks ago about a young man called Nick Fuentes, who's become very big in the United States, with a fan base called the Groypers. What really struck me was his interview with Piers Morgan a few months ago. Without any appearance of shame, he expressed what you could bracket as revisionist sentiments about the Holocaust. He wasn't specifically disputing how many Jews died. That's all on the historical record. But he felt he had permission to challenge the narrative. Piers patched in a recording of someone saying, "I'm really offended by this, because my parents were in the Holocaust." And Fuentes' reaction was basically to put his hand up: "Talk to the hand. I don't care. We've got our own thinking."
Then there's the idea of presentism: living in the present and looking back at the past only through the lens of how we see things now. It struck me as quite profound. What is it about the current generation, and we're part of it too, that we forget, and think differently about the past from previous generations? Worse still, if we forget, we're doomed to repeat history. That's really disturbed me, but I believe there's some hope hiding in there as well.
Neil: It's easier than ever to drift away from historical facts, and historical facts matter. This "we don't worry about the facts, we have our own view" attitude seems to have spread to other commentators like Tucker Carlson, people who are very influential. That's probably having a broader effect, do you think?
Alister: Well, Nick has the excuse that he's a young man. He's in his twenties, which puts him in Gen Z. Tucker has no such excuse. He's exactly my age. A year or two ago Tucker interviewed someone he presented as a legitimate historian, and his listeners followed along, who said Churchill was the real villain of World War II, not Hitler. Tucker has a way of letting people speak while he wears a very stern look, but it was really disingenuous, and it fed that fire.
The three-generation rule
Alister: I'd point to another commentator, Konstantin Kisin, from the show Trigonometry, who teases this out helpfully. He points to what we could call a three-generation rule, and there's some science behind it. Unless you've heard first-person, eyewitness accounts from your parents' or grandparents' generation, you lose a sense of emotional connection. You inherit a different kind of memory.
In my case, my mum and dad literally went through World War II. My dad got shunted off to boarding school in Devon because the Blitz was on. My mum is French, and her mother, a single mother, drove nearly all the way to Spain. The family joke is that she didn't know how to drive in reverse, so she just kept going. My parents have vivid memories of World War II, and my grandmother had memories of World War I. But if you ask me about the Napoleonic Wars, Neil, I have no emotional attachment to them whatsoever. My knowledge is academic at best.
Academics distinguish between communicative memory, the memories you inherit from someone who tells them to you, with the emotion and lived experience attached, and what comes after that, which is cultural memory. Cultural memory is a different kind of thing. It doesn't stick the same way, and it doesn't teach its lessons in the same way. We see the symptoms of that in a Nick Fuentes and a Tucker Carlson, who have huge followings, and social media has become a very good platform for promoting doubt and distortion.
What the surveys show
Neil: So if you don't have that personal connection to the past through parents and grandparents, you're open to doubt and distortion. There are some studies on this. A global survey across eight Western nations, including the US, the UK and France, found that among 18 to 29-year-olds, up to 46 per cent in some countries had not heard of the Holocaust or were unsure it had occurred. Around 3 per cent flatly denied it, and up to 48 per cent couldn't name a single camp. In Australia, the Gandel Holocaust Knowledge and Awareness Survey with Deakin University in 2021 found around 80 per cent knew it occurred in the correct time frame, but 20 to 25 per cent either lacked specific knowledge or underestimated the death toll. So perhaps one in four young people here hold some of these distortions and doubts. Given your stories about your son and others, that sounds pretty real. Does it strike a chord?
Alister: It absolutely does. The studies validate it very well. What it points to is that every generation has to work out what matters and how to tell that story, and sometimes go further and enshrine it in the culture, so it sticks with generations who, simply because of time, can't receive the memory that comes through conversation. The only memory left is what's been built into the culture.
There are numerous influences we can rightly be critical of, and in the church, I'd say we need to think long and hard about how we pass on these truths, which we can come back to. Kisin is very critical of modern education. Instead of teaching what happened, schools often teach students the skills of critique. So they learn critical skills rather than taking in and understanding the experience of others, and you end up with an empathy gap.
When you tell a story well, you communicate the emotion and the heart as much as what actually happened, and one of the most powerful ways to do that is first-person narrative. We have no excuse for not doing that today. When I was at school I saw footage of World War II, and testimonies from men and women who survived Dachau, Buchenwald, Auschwitz and the other camps. They don't show those in schools anymore. There's very little on World War II in the average high school history or English curriculum. We could go on about that, but it will have its logical effect once there's no one left to tell the story.
Neil: We need to teach young children concrete facts, and then teach critical thinking as they grow into their teenage years so they can resist being taken off on all sorts of tangents. Educators and various organisations are calling for better Holocaust education, digital literacy and stronger platform safeguards. But as a parent, you've got to take some responsibility, haven't you?
A universal human story
Alister: Yes, you do. And as a society we need to think seriously about what we value. In the case of the Holocaust, there's an argument that it's not only a story about the Jewish people and a European population. It's grounded in those specifics, but it's more than that. It's the story of what humans are capable of doing to humans under certain conditions: authoritarianism, a certain kind of influence, the chemistry of what was in the water in 1930s Germany, how it led to the rise of Hitler, the story he sold, who he sold it to and why it sold. That's very powerful. In a sense it goes beyond history. It tells a universal human story, and every generation desperately needs to hear its lessons. So I'm all for teaching the Holocaust, not only in the context of explaining Israel today, but because it teaches very powerful, universal lessons about sin and righteousness.
Neil: We often talk on this program about recognising what revisionism looks like. Revisionism relativises things we should understand as fact. When a historical atrocity like the Holocaust, the death of six million Jews, is denied or revised, what's to stop the same logic turning against the historical claims of the gospel itself, the crucifixion and resurrection of Jesus? If you can't say that what happened within the last hundred years is historically true, how will you get your head around things that happened 2000 years ago?
A generation that did not know
Alister: You're absolutely right. There's a striking scripture in Judges 2:7–10, for anyone who wants to follow along: "The people served the Lord throughout the lifetime of Joshua and of the elders who outlived him... After that whole generation had been gathered to their ancestors, another generation grew up who knew neither the Lord nor what he had done for Israel."
That's after Moses and Joshua presented the law, restated it, laid it all out in full more than once. The amount of work the Moseses, the Joshuas and the elders put into keeping the truth of Israel's history alive! Yet by the time of the judges, there's a generation that didn't know Moses or Joshua, and they strayed.
So even in our Christian and Jewish story, we need to develop the ability to remember, to work out what matters, and to build it into our life together. The Mosaic Law makes it really clear that you won't do this automatically. Here's the Passover Seder, and a range of other festivals and traditions to keep. Here's the mezuzah and the phylacteries, and tassels on your garments to remind you constantly. Here's the command in Deuteronomy 6:7 to impress these things on your children.
I've had a personal aspiration that Christians would return to more of the Jewish festivals. Yes, we've Christianised them, and that's perfectly fine. But the Passover Seder, for example, is a profound way not only to reflect on its Jewishness but to overlay the wisdom of God in what Jesus has done as the Passover lamb. Or the church returning to the liturgical calendar, or some variation of it, where we keep telling the same stories because we need to, because it constantly reinforces who we are and what matters to us.
Neil: That's a good aspiration, because the Jewish people have had a very good way of passing their stories down from one generation to the next. Mainline churches have a liturgical calendar that brings people around to the same history each year, but evangelical and Pentecostal churches have very little of that structured remembering. That might get us thinking.
Lest we forget
Neil: It doesn't escape me, talking about the Holocaust, that this Saturday is Anzac Day. In our Anzac tradition we remember Gallipoli and the atrocities of war, and that might include the Holocaust as well. What are your thoughts?
Alister: If you get up very early on Saturday morning, you'll notice that every year there are fewer and fewer people who were actually there. "Lest we forget" means something very specific to someone who couldn't forget even if they wanted to, because they were there. For the rest of us, "lest we forget" is a reminder that it's possible to forget something you never experienced firsthand.
With each passing generation, and fewer eyewitnesses in the Anzac tradition, you see Afghanistan becoming part of the Anzac Day conversation, because it's more relevant to people who were actually there. Then there's Vietnam, the boomer generation's war, and more recently Afghanistan. It's easy to remember when you were there. So even in the Anzac tradition we're drawing, as much as we can, on people who actually took part in war, because then what we're remembering comes from lived experience. That tells a compelling story and connects us to our children, who hear the narrative of our own lives. But as there are fewer and fewer diggers, from any generation, it becomes a different exercise to keep those memories alive. I wonder how the Anzac folk are thinking that through.
Neil: And when you've got grandparents or great-grandparents who are veterans, it's a good thing to raise these things at family gatherings. A lot of veterans don't like to talk about their experience of war, but it might be more important than they think, if their grandchildren might not believe the facts of history. That's something you can do in your own family.
The intergenerational table
Alister: I love the idea of an intergenerational table. I don't know if you've noticed this, Neil, but around really old people, the things from way back in their past are as real to them as what they had for breakfast, and often more so. They're super keen to sit and talk about things from long ago. So sitting down at a table with Grandad or Great-grandad and asking about the old stories is a rich and precious thing to do. It should be sacramentalised, Neil. It should be a holy thing, because it's so precious.
My father is 96, bless him, and going like a machine. There's no stopping him. Dad tells some really hilarious stories. I thought I'd heard them all, but I haven't. What a precious thing it is to sit with the older generations and ask them to bring history to life. Mostly they're very happy to do it.
Neil: And these days you don't just write those stories down. You can video them on your phone and keep them for posterity, because your children, your grandchildren and future generations might need the truth that comes from eyewitness accounts. That way revisionism can be held back in your own family, and you can keep a focus on truth, the same truth that matters when we talk about the things of the gospel.
You can connect with Alister at powertochange.org.au and finishingthetask.com. Alister, what a great topic. Thanks so much for raising it with us this morning on 20twenty.
Alister: My pleasure, Neil. Thank you so much for having me.


